A member’s state may give additional rights to limit sharing of health information
The notice says the member’s state may give additional rights to limit the sharing of health information. For more details it tells members to call the Customer Service number on their ID card.
Supporting quotations
Your state may give you additional rights to limit sharing your health information.
Please call the Customer Service phone number on your ID card for more details.
Qualifications & exceptions
Extra rights exist only if the member’s state provides them ("may give").
Not stated here
The text does not say which state rights exist or whether any apply to this member, and it names no state.
The sender may collect, use and share personal information as described, sometimes without approval
The sender says it may collect, use and share the member’s personal information (PI) as the notice describes. It also says it may share PI with others outside the company without the member’s approval in some cases.
Supporting quotations
We may collect, use, and share your PI as described in this notice.
We may also share your PI with others outside our company
without your approval, in some cases
Qualifications & exceptions
Sharing without approval is limited to "some cases".
Collection, use and sharing are tied to what "this notice" describes.
Not stated here
This passage does not say which cases allow sharing without approval or who the outside parties are.
When an activity requires an opt-out chance, the sender says it will tell the member and explain how
The sender says that if an activity requires it to give the member a chance to opt out, it will tell the member. It will also tell the member how to say they do not want their personal information (PI) used or shared for that activity.
Supporting quotations
If an activity requires us to give you a chance to opt out, we’ll let you know and we’ll let you know how to tell us you don’t want your PI used or shared for an activity you can opt out of.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies only to an activity that requires giving the member an opt-out chance.
Not stated here
The notice does not list which activities carry an opt-out or how to use one.
The sender does not provide treatment but uses and shares treatment information to offer services
Under the Treatment activities heading, the sender says it does not provide treatment. It says it still collects, uses and shares information about the member’s treatment to offer services that may help the member. That includes sharing information with others who provide the member treatment.
Supporting quotations
We don’t provide treatment, but we collect, use and share information about your treatment to offer services that may help you, including sharing information with others providing you treatment.
Qualifications & exceptions
The sender states it does not itself provide treatment.
Sharing includes people providing the member’s treatment.
Not stated here
The passage does not say which services "may help" the member.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may give information to a doctor’s office to confirm benefits
As an example, the sender says it may give information to a doctor’s office to confirm the member’s benefits.
Supporting quotations
We may give information to a doctor’s office to confirm your benefits.
Qualifications & exceptions
The stated purpose is confirming benefits; the sentence says "may", so it describes a permitted practice.
Not stated here
The sentence does not say what information is given.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may share an Explanation of Benefits with the plan subscriber for payment purposes
As an example, the sender says it may share an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) with the subscriber of the member’s plan for payment purposes.
Supporting quotations
We may share Explanation of Benefits (EOB) with the subscriber of your plan for payment purposes.
Qualifications & exceptions
The recipient is the "subscriber of your plan" and the stated purpose is payment.
Not stated here
The text does not say whether the subscriber is the member or a different person. Whether the member can limit these EOB mailings is not stated here; a later rights list covers confidential communications.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may share PHI with the member’s doctor or hospital so they can treat the member
As an example, the sender says it may share PHI with the member’s doctor or hospital so that they may treat the member.
Supporting quotations
We may share PHI with your doctor or hospital so that they may treat you.
Qualifications & exceptions
The stated purpose is treatment of the member by their own doctor or hospital.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may use and share PHI directly or indirectly with health information exchanges
As an example, the sender says it may use and share PHI, directly or indirectly, with health information exchanges. The listed purposes are payment, health care operations and treatment.
Supporting quotations
We may also use and share PHI directly or indirectly with health information exchanges for payment, health care operations, and treatment.
Qualifications & exceptions
Sharing is for payment, health care operations and treatment.
Not stated here
The notice does not name the exchanges or explain what "indirectly" means.
In most cases, written permission is needed to use or share PHI outside treatment, payment, operations or research
The sender says that in most cases, if it uses or shares PHI outside treatment, payment, operations or research activities, it has to get the member’s okay in writing first. It adds that it may also need written permission for other situations the notice does not mention.
Supporting quotations
In most cases, if we use or share your PHI outside of treatment, payment, operations, or research activities, we have to get your okay in writing first.
We may also need your written permission for other situations not mentioned above.
Qualifications & exceptions
The rule applies "in most cases", so some cases are outside it.
Treatment, payment, operations and research activities are outside the written-okay rule.
Written permission may also be needed in other unmentioned situations ("may also need").
Not stated here
The notice does not say which cases are the exceptions to "most cases". A later section lists purposes for which the sender may share information, and this passage does not say whether written permission applies to them.
Cross-references
contrast (model-proposed): Written permission is needed for any purpose the notice does not state — One sentence says written permission is needed "in most cases" outside treatment, payment, operations or research activities. Another says written permission is needed for any purpose not stated in the notice. The notice states many purposes beyond those four, and it does not say how the two formulations fit together.
Written permission is required before certain marketing, selling PHI, or sharing psychotherapy notes
The sender says it must also get the member’s written permission before it does three things. It must get permission before using PHI for certain marketing activities, before selling PHI, and before sharing any psychotherapy notes from the member’s doctor or therapist.
Supporting quotations
We must also get your written permission before:
Using your PHI for certain marketing activities.
Selling your PHI.
Sharing any psychotherapy notes from your doctor or therapist.
Qualifications & exceptions
Marketing is covered only for "certain" marketing activities.
Psychotherapy notes covered are those "from your doctor or therapist".
Not stated here
The notice does not say which marketing activities count as "certain" marketing activities.
Members can tell the sender to share information with family or friends involved in their care, or in emergencies
The sender says the member has the right and choice to tell it to share information with family, close friends or others involved with the member’s current treatment or payment for care. The member can also tell the sender to share information in an emergency or disaster relief situation.
Supporting quotations
You have the right and choice to tell us to:
Share information with your family, close friends, or others involved with your current treatment or payment for your care.
Share information in an emergency or disaster relief situation.
Qualifications & exceptions
Family, friends or others must be involved with the member’s current treatment or payment for care.
The second choice is limited to emergency or disaster relief situations.
Not stated here
The notice does not say how a member records this choice. The listed federal rights are used by calling Customer Service, but this choice is not in that list.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
If a member cannot state a preference, the sender may share PHI when it believes that is in the member’s best interest
The sender says that if the member cannot state a preference, for example in an emergency or when unconscious, it may share the member’s PHI if it believes that is in the member’s best interest.
Supporting quotations
If you can’t tell us your preference, for example, in an emergency or if you’re unconscious, we may share your PHI if we believe it’s in your best interest.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies only if the member "can’t tell us" their preference.
Depends on the sender’s own belief about the member’s best interest.
Not stated here
The passage does not say who may receive the PHI or what limits apply.
The sender may share information when needed to lessen a serious and likely threat to health or safety
The sender says it may share the member’s information when needed to lessen a serious and likely threat to the member’s health or safety.
Supporting quotations
We may also share your information when needed to lessen a serious and likely threat to your health or safety.
Qualifications & exceptions
Only when sharing is "needed" and the threat is "serious and likely".
Not stated here
The passage does not say who may receive the information. The public-safety list later refers to a threat to "anyone’s" health or safety, while this sentence says "your".
The sender may share information for listed public-benefit and legal purposes, sometimes required to
The sender says it is allowed, and in some cases required, to share the member’s information in other ways, usually for the good of the public, such as public health and research. It says it can share information for the specific purposes that follow in the list.
Supporting quotations
We are allowed, and in some cases required, to share your information in other ways — usually for the good of the public, such as public health and research. We can share your information for these specific purposes:
Qualifications & exceptions
Sharing is allowed "and in some cases required".
Purposes are "usually" for the good of the public, so not every listed purpose is a public-benefit purpose.
Sharing is limited to the listed "specific purposes".
Not stated here
This passage does not say whether written permission is needed for these purposes. The notice’s "most cases" written-permission rule and this list are not expressly linked.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may share information for public health and safety, such as disease prevention, recalls and abuse reports
The list of purposes includes public health and safety issues. The examples are preventing disease, helping with product recalls, reporting adverse reactions to medicines, reporting suspected abuse, neglect or domestic violence, and preventing or reducing a serious threat to anyone’s health or safety.
Supporting quotations
Helping with public health and safety issues, such as:
Preventing disease
Helping with product recalls
Reporting adverse reactions to medicines
Reporting suspected abuse, neglect, or domestic violence
Preventing or reducing a serious threat to anyone’s health or safety
Qualifications & exceptions
The examples follow "such as", so they are not a complete list of public health and safety issues.
Not stated here
The passage does not say who receives the information for these purposes.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may share information to do health research
The list of purposes includes doing health research. The earlier written-permission rule names research activities, together with treatment, payment and operations, as outside the "in most cases" requirement.
Supporting quotations
Doing health research
Qualifications & exceptions
Listed among the specific purposes for which the sender "can share" information.
Not stated here
The notice does not say which research, which recipients or what limits apply.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may share information for workers’ compensation, law enforcement, other government requests and abuse alerts
The list of purposes includes addressing workers’ compensation, law enforcement and other government requests. It also includes alerting proper authorities if the sender believes the member may be a victim of abuse or other crimes.
Supporting quotations
Addressing workers’ compensation, law enforcement, and other government requests, and to alert proper authorities if we believe you may be a victim of abuse or other crimes
Qualifications & exceptions
Alerting authorities depends on the sender believing the member may be a victim of abuse or other crimes.
Not stated here
The notice does not define "other government requests" or say which authorities receive an alert.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
The sender may respond to organ donation groups for research and certain reasons
The list of purposes includes responding to organ donation groups for research and certain reasons. The wording does not make clear whether "for research and certain reasons" describes the purposes of the responses or the groups.
Supporting quotations
Responding to organ donation groups for research and certain reasons
Qualifications & exceptions
Limited to "research and certain reasons".
Not stated here
The notice does not say what the "certain reasons" are, and the phrase is ambiguous as written.
Sharing & Disclosure · Permission or license
For members enrolled through an employer, the sender may share PHI with the group health plan
The sender says that if the member is enrolled through an employer, it may share the member’s PHI with the group health plan.
Supporting quotations
If you’re enrolled with us through an employer, we may share your PHI with your group health plan.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies only if the member is "enrolled with us through an employer".
Not stated here
The notice does not say whether this member’s coverage is employer-based.
An employer that pays only premiums can get PHI only for permitted reasons and must protect it
The sender says that if the employer pays all or part of the premium but does not pay the member’s health insurance claims, the employer can have the member’s PHI only for permitted reasons. The employer is required by law to protect it.
Supporting quotations
If the employer pays your premium or part of it, but doesn’t pay your health insurance claims, your employer can only have your PHI for permitted reasons and is required by law to protect it.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies where the employer pays the premium or part of it but does not pay the health insurance claims.
Not stated here
The notice does not list the permitted reasons or say what applies when the employer pays claims.
Written permission is needed for any purpose the notice does not state
The sender says it will get the member’s written permission before it uses or shares PHI for any purpose not stated in the notice. The earlier rule says written permission is needed "in most cases" outside treatment, payment, operations or research. This sentence is worded around purposes the notice does not state.
Supporting quotations
We’ll get your written permission before we use or share your PHI for any purpose not stated in this notice.
In most cases, if we use or share your PHI outside of treatment, payment, operations, or research activities, we have to get your okay in writing first.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to purposes "not stated in this notice".
Not stated here
The notice does not reconcile this sentence with the earlier "in most cases" rule, including whether the purposes it lists in the public-benefit section need written permission.
Cross-references
contrast (model-proposed): In most cases, written permission is needed to use or share PHI outside treatment, payment, operations or research — One sentence says written permission is needed "in most cases" outside treatment, payment, operations or research activities. Another says written permission is needed for any purpose not stated in the notice. The notice states many purposes beyond those four, and it does not say how the two formulations fit together.
Members can ask in writing for a list of those with whom their PHI was shared, usually within 60 days
Under federal law the member can send a written request for a list of those with whom the sender has shared their PHI. The sender will provide the list usually within 60 days. If it needs more time, it will let the member know.
Supporting quotations
Send us a written request to ask us for a list of those with whom we’ve shared your PHI. We will provide you a list usually within 60 days of your request. If we need more time, we will let you know.
Qualifications & exceptions
The request must be written.
The 60-day timing is "usually", not a fixed deadline.
Not stated here
The notice does not say which disclosures the list includes or how far back it goes.
Sharing & Disclosure · Restriction or exception
Where the law requires, business partners must protect shared data and cannot pass PHI on without written permission
The sender says that, where the law requires it, its business partners must protect the privacy of data the sender shares with them. The partners may not give the member’s PHI to others without the member’s written permission, unless the law allows it and the notice states it. As worded, the exception says "unless the law allows it, and it’s stated in this notice".
Supporting quotations
Also, where required by law, our business partners must protect the privacy of data we share with them as they work with us.
They’re not allowed to give your PHI to others without your written permission, unless the law allows it, and it’s stated in this notice.
Qualifications & exceptions
The partner protection duty applies "where required by law".
The exception to the written-permission requirement is worded with "and", joining the law allowing it and the notice stating it.
Not stated here
The notice does not say whether both conditions in the exception must be met, how the notice’s list of purposes applies to partners, or who the partners are.
SUD information from regulated providers follows federal and state law, with some treatment, payment and operations use
The notice gives substance use disorder (SUD) information the sender may receive from providers or programs regulated by federal law (42 CFR Part 2) as an example of a stricter rule. All disclosures of that SUD information must comply with applicable federal and state privacy laws, including 42 CFR Part 2. The sender is allowed to use and disclose SUD information for certain treatment, payment and health care operations activities.
Supporting quotations
One example is with Substance Use Disorder (SUD) Information we may receive from Providers or programs regulated by federal law (42 CFR Part 2). All disclosures of such SUD information must comply with applicable Federal and State privacy laws, including 42 CFR Part 2.
We are allowed to Use and Disclose SUD information for certain Treatment, Payment, and Health Care Operations activities.
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers SUD information received from providers or programs regulated by 42 CFR Part 2.
Use and disclosure for treatment, payment and health care operations is allowed only for "certain" activities.
Not stated here
The text of 42 CFR Part 2 is not supplied here. The notice does not say which treatment, payment or operations activities are allowed.
Members can consent to disclosure of SUD information in certain circumstances and revoke consent in writing
The sender says the member has the right to consent to the disclosure of substance use disorder (SUD) information in certain circumstances. The member can revoke that consent in writing at any time.
Supporting quotations
You have the right to consent to the disclosure of SUD information in certain circumstances. You can revoke this consent in writing at any time.
Qualifications & exceptions
The consent right applies "in certain circumstances".
Revocation must be in writing.
Not stated here
The notice does not say what the circumstances are or how to give or revoke consent.