Google may make exceptions to the policies for artistic, educational, documentary, scientific or public-benefit reasons
When applying the policies on the page, Google may make exceptions based on artistic, educational, documentary or scientific considerations, or where there are other substantial benefits to the public from not taking action on the content. The wording is discretionary ("may"), so the page does not promise an exception in any given case.
Supporting quotations
when applying the policies below, we may make exceptions based on artistic, educational, documentary, or scientific considerations or where there are other substantial benefits to the public from not taking action on the content
Qualifications & exceptions
Exceptions are discretionary ("may").
Based on artistic, educational, documentary or scientific considerations, or other substantial public benefit from not taking action.
Not stated here
The passage refers to "the policies below" without saying whether the exceptions reach the zero tolerance child safety policy.
Cross-references
contrast (model-proposed): Google has a zero tolerance policy toward content that exploits children — The page says Google may make exceptions to 'the policies below' on artistic, educational, documentary, scientific or public-benefit grounds, and also states a zero tolerance policy toward content that exploits children. The source does not say whether the exceptions reach the zero tolerance policy.
Adult content is allowed on Google Groups if you mark your group as 'adult'
Google Groups allows adult content, including images or videos that contain nudity or sexual activity. You must mark your group as 'adult' in your settings. The page then says there are exceptions to this adult content policy, set out in the paragraphs that follow.
Supporting quotations
We do allow adult content on Google Groups, including images or videos that contain nudity or sexual activity. But, you must mark your group as 'adult' in your settings.
There are some exceptions to our adult content policy:
Qualifications & exceptions
You must mark your group as 'adult' in your settings.
Subject to the exceptions the page lists.
Not stated here
The page does not say what marking a group 'adult' changes for viewers or what happens to a group that is not marked.
The extracted text does not show where the list of exceptions ends.
Cross-references
has exception (model-proposed): You may not use Groups to make money on adult content — Adult content is allowed with the 'adult' setting, and the paragraph on using Groups to make money on adult content follows the lead-in about exceptions to the adult content policy.
You may not use Groups to make money on adult content
Do not use Groups as a way to make money on adult content. The page's example is linking to commercial porn websites in your posts in order to make money. This is listed after the lead-in about exceptions to the adult content policy.
Supporting quotations
Do not use Groups as a way to make money on adult content.
don’t link to commercial porn websites in order to make money in your posts
Qualifications & exceptions
The restriction targets using Groups as a way to make money; the page's example is linking to commercial porn websites in order to make money.
Not stated here
This passage does not say whether a link to such a site without a money-making purpose is allowed.
Non-consensual or illegal sexual content, including content that depicts or encourages rape, is not allowed
Google does not allow non-consensual or illegal sexual content. The page says this includes image, video or textual content that depicts or encourages rape, incest, bestiality, or necrophilia.
Supporting quotations
We do not allow non-consensual or illegal sexual content, including image, video or textual content that depicts or encourages rape, incest, bestiality, or necrophilia.
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers image, video and textual content.
Not stated here
The page does not define "illegal sexual content" beyond the acts named after "including."
If someone posted a private intimate image or video of you, the page asks you to report it to Google
If someone has posted a private nude, sexually explicit, or non-explicit intimate and sexual image or video of you, the page asks you to report it to Google. The page gives a link for doing so; the linked page is not part of the supplied text.
Supporting quotations
If someone has posted a private nude, sexually explicit, or non-explicit intimate and sexual image or video of you, please report it to us
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies when someone has posted a private intimate image or video of you.
Not stated here
The linked reporting page is not supplied, so its steps and what follows a report are unknown.
Google has a zero tolerance policy toward content that exploits children
The page states a zero tolerance policy toward content that exploits children and introduces examples. The examples that follow are child sexual abuse imagery and content that encourages or promotes sexual attraction towards children.
Supporting quotations
We have a zero tolerance policy towards content that exploits children. Some examples of this include:
Qualifications & exceptions
The listed items are examples ("Some examples of this include"), not a complete list.
Not stated here
The page says elsewhere that Google may make exceptions when applying the policies below, but this passage does not say whether those exceptions reach this zero tolerance policy.
Content that encourages or promotes sexual attraction towards children is not allowed
Google does not allow content that encourages or promotes sexual attraction towards children. The page's example is groups or messages with galleries of images of children where the collection of images, or the text accompanying the images, is sexually suggestive.
Supporting quotations
We do not allow content that encourages or promotes sexual attraction towards children.
do not create groups or post messages with galleries of images of children where the collection of images or text accompanying the images is sexually suggestive
Qualifications & exceptions
The example turns on galleries of images of children being sexually suggestive, either in the collection or in the accompanying text.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Hate speech, meaning content that promotes hate or violence toward groups based on listed traits, is not allowed
Google wants users to express their opinions on Groups, even very controversial ones, but not to publish hate speech. The page defines hate speech as content that promotes hate or violence towards groups based on race, ethnicity, nationality, religion, disability, gender, age, veteran status, or sexual orientation/gender identity. Its examples are a post saying that members of Race X are criminals and a post advocating violence against followers of Religion Y.
Supporting quotations
We want you to use Google Groups to express your opinions, even very controversial ones. But, don't cross the line by publishing hate speech.
content that promotes hate or violence towards groups based on race, ethnicity, nationality, religion, disability, gender, age, veteran status, or sexual orientation/gender identity
don't write a post saying that members of Race X are criminals or advocating violence against followers of Religion Y
Qualifications & exceptions
Hate speech is defined as content that promotes hate or violence towards groups based on the listed characteristics.
Controversial opinions are welcomed up to that line.
Not stated here
The page does not say how it decides whether content "promotes" hate or violence.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Do not post content just to be shocking or graphic
Do not post content just to be shocking or graphic. The page's example is a collection of close-up images of gunshot wounds or accident scenes without additional context or commentary, which it says would violate the policy.
Supporting quotations
Don't post content just to be shocking or graphic.
collections of close-up images of gunshot wounds or accident scenes without additional context or commentary would violate this policy
Qualifications & exceptions
Aimed at content posted "just to be shocking or graphic."
The example turns on the absence of additional context or commentary.
Not stated here
The page does not say how much context or commentary is enough.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Do not threaten people or encourage violent action against them
Don't threaten other people on your group or messages. The page's examples are death threats against another person or group of people and content encouraging your readers to take violent action against another person or group of people.
Supporting quotations
Don't threaten other people on your group or messages.
don't post death threats against another person or group of people and don't post content encouraging your readers to take violent action against another person or group of people
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Known violent non-state organizations may not use the product, and content that promotes their activities is barred
Known violent non-state organizations and movements are not permitted to use this product for any purpose. Users must not distribute content that facilitates or promotes their activities, such as recruiting, coordinating online or offline activities, sharing manuals or other materials that could facilitate harm, promoting their ideologies, promoting terrorist acts, inciting violence, or celebrating their attacks. Depending on the content, Google may also take action against the user.
Supporting quotations
Known violent non-state organizations and movements are not permitted to use this product for any purpose.
Do not distribute content that facilitates or promotes the activities of these groups, such as recruiting, coordinating online or offline activities, sharing manuals or other materials that could facilitate harm, promoting ideologies of violent non-state organizations, promoting terrorist acts, inciting violence, or celebrating attacks by violent non-state organizations.
Depending upon the content, we may also take action against the user.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to "known" violent non-state organizations and movements.
Action against the user depends on the content ("Depending upon the content") and is discretionary ("may").
Not stated here
The page does not say who decides which organizations or movements count as known violent non-state organizations.
Content on violent non-state organizations may be allowed in educational, documentary, scientific or artistic contexts
Content related to violent non-state organizations may be allowed in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context. The page asks users to be mindful to provide enough information to help people understand the context.
Supporting quotations
Content related to violent non-state organizations may be allowed in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context, but please be mindful to provide enough information to help people understand the context.
Qualifications & exceptions
Only in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context.
The user should provide enough information to help people understand the context.
Not stated here
The page does not say how much information is enough, or who decides.
Do not harass or bully others; offending content may be removed and offenders permanently banned
Do not harass or bully others. The page says anyone using Google Groups to harass or bully may have the offending content removed or be permanently banned from the site. It adds that online harassment is also illegal in many places and can have serious offline consequences.
Supporting quotations
Do not harass or bully others.
Anyone using Google Groups to harass or bully may have the offending content removed or be permanently banned from the site.
Online harassment is also illegal in many places and can have serious offline consequences.
Qualifications & exceptions
Consequences are stated as possibilities ("may have the offending content removed or be permanently banned").
Not stated here
The page does not define "the site" or say how a ban is decided.
Content & IP Rights · Company commitment
Google's policy is to respond to clear notices of alleged copyright infringement
The page says it is Google's policy to respond to clear notices of alleged copyright infringement. It points to a linked page for more information about copyright procedures; that linked page is not part of the supplied text.
Supporting quotations
It is our policy to respond to clear notices of alleged copyright infringement.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to "clear" notices of alleged copyright infringement.
Not stated here
The linked copyright procedures are not supplied, so what a response involves is unknown.
The page does not say what makes a notice "clear."
Do not publish another person's personal and confidential information
It is not ok to publish another person's personal and confidential information. The page's examples are someone else's credit card numbers, Social Security numbers, unlisted phone numbers, and driver's license numbers. The page also says that in most cases, information already available elsewhere on the Internet or in public records is not considered private or confidential under these policies.
Supporting quotations
It's not ok to publish another person's personal and confidential information.
don't post someone else's credit card numbers, Social Security numbers, unlisted phone numbers, and driver's license numbers
in most cases, information that is already available elsewhere on the Internet or in public records is not considered to be private or confidential under our policies
Qualifications & exceptions
Information already available elsewhere on the Internet or in public records is, in most cases, not considered private or confidential under these policies.
Not stated here
The page does not say which cases are not covered by the "in most cases" statement.
Information already available elsewhere online or in public records is usually not treated as private or confidential
The page tells readers to keep in mind that, in most cases, information that is already available elsewhere on the Internet or in public records is not considered private or confidential under its policies.
Supporting quotations
in most cases, information that is already available elsewhere on the Internet or in public records is not considered to be private or confidential under our policies
Qualifications & exceptions
Stated for "most cases," not all cases.
Not stated here
The page does not say which cases are not covered.
Cross-references
narrows (model-proposed): Do not publish another person's personal and confidential information — Information already available elsewhere online or in public records is, in most cases, not considered private or confidential, which narrows what the ban on publishing personal and confidential information covers.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Misleading content may be allowed with educational, documentary, scientific or artistic context, but not always
The page says misleading content may be allowed in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context, and asks users to be mindful to provide enough information to help people understand this context. It adds that in some cases no amount of context will allow this content to remain on its platforms. This sits alongside the page's earlier statement that Google may make exceptions on artistic, educational, documentary or scientific grounds.
Supporting quotations
Misleading content may be allowed in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context, but please be mindful to provide enough information to help people understand this context.
In some cases, no amount of context will allow this content to remain on our platforms.
when applying the policies below, we may make exceptions based on artistic, educational, documentary, or scientific considerations or where there are other substantial benefits to the public from not taking action on the content
Qualifications & exceptions
Allowed only in an educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context.
In some cases no amount of context allows the content to remain.
Not stated here
The page does not say which cases are ones where no amount of context is enough.
The page does not say which platforms "our platforms" covers.
Cross-references
exception to (model-proposed): Do not distribute content that deceives, misleads or confuses users — Misleading content may be allowed in an educational, documentary, scientific or artistic context, though in some cases no amount of context is enough; this limits the ban on misleading content.