Supplemental Rules for Mass Arbitration Filings

Replit · Official agreement

Read the agreement

23 of 29 cards in Legal Rights & Agreement Rules

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Context

These rules supplement NAM arbitration rules for qualifying mass filings

The Supplemental Rules apply to disputes that meet the mass-filing criteria and that the parties mutually agree NAM will administer. They supplement NAM’s Comprehensive and/or Employment rules, as applicable, and control if those NAM rules conflict. Terms undefined here take their meanings from the applicable NAM rules.

Supporting quotations

All rules set forth herein are NAM’s (National Arbitration & Mediation) Mass Filing Supplemental Dispute Resolution Rules and Procedures (hereinafter “Supplemental Rules”) and shall apply to the administration of disputes that are classified as part of a “Mass Filing” pursuant to the criteria set forth herein and that are administered by NAM by the parties’ mutual agreement.
These rules supplement NAM’s Comprehensive Dispute Resolution Rules and/or NAM’s Employment Rules and Procedures, as applicable, in instances in which there has been a Mass Filing. In the event of an inconsistency between these Supplemental Rules and any other applicable NAM rules, these Supplemental Rules shall govern.
Terms not defined herein are as defined in the applicable NAM rules.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • NAM administration requires the parties’ mutual agreement.

Not stated here

  • The referenced Comprehensive and Employment rules and their additional definitions are not supplied in this document.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Context

The rules aim for prompt, private and cost-effective case resolution

NAM describes these rules as designed to resolve multiple cases expeditiously, privately and cost-effectively, whether the cases seek legal or equitable relief. This describes their purpose; it does not specify a completion deadline or guarantee a particular cost.

Supporting quotations

These Supplemental Rules are designed to secure the most expeditious, private and cost-effective resolution and determination of multiple cases, whether in law or equity.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Context

A mass filing involves at least 25 similar arbitration demands

A Mass Filing consists of 25 or more similar arbitration demands against the same or related parties, with consistent or coordinated representation across all cases. The demands do not have to arrive simultaneously.

Supporting quotations

“Mass Filing” shall be defined as the filing of twenty-five (25) or more similar Demands for Arbitration (“Demand(s)”) against the same party or related parties and representation for the parties is consistent or coordinated across all cases. The twenty-five (25) or more Demands need not be filed simultaneously.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Demands must target the same or related parties and have consistent or coordinated representation.
Also annotated in the same passage (2)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

NAM decides mass-filing status, subject to a requested procedural review

NAM has sole discretion to classify demands as a Mass Filing and to apply or interpret these Supplemental Rules. Either party disputing the classification may request a Procedural Arbitrator within five business days of the specified NAM notice and before merits arbitrators are appointed. That review is limited to mass-filing status and the resulting rules or requirements, and, for mass-filed demands, compliance with the underlying contractual arbitration provision.

Supporting quotations

The determination of whether or not a Demand/Demands is/are part of a “Mass Filing” is in NAM’s sole discretion; however, either party can request the appointment of a Procedural Arbitrator pursuant to Rule No. 7 if they do not agree with NAM’s determination. In addition, the applicability and/or interpretation of these Supplemental Rules shall be in NAM’s sole discretion.
A. In the event a party does not agree with NAM’s determination that a Demand(s) should or should not be classified as part of a Mass Filing, or believes that a Demand(s) has/have not been filed in accordance with the underlying contractual arbitration provision, and prior to the appointment of the Arbitrator(s) who will determine each case, either party, within five (5) business days of being notified by NAM that such Demand(s) has/have been filed and/or NAM’s determination of whether or not the Demand(s) is/are part of a Mass Filing, may file a Request for Appointment of a Procedural Arbitrator with NAM and copy the other parties to the matter.
B. The Procedural Arbitrator’s review shall be limited to: (1) whether or not a particular Demand(s) is/are part of a Mass Filing as defined herein and the applicable rules, procedures or requirements based on that determination and/or (2) if a Demand(s) is/are categorized as part of a Mass Filing, whether or not the particular Demand(s) was/were filed in accordance with the terms and conditions of the underlying contractual arbitration provision.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • A review request must precede appointment of the arbitrators deciding the cases.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (2)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Permission or license

NAM may change the rules without prior written notice

NAM reserves the right to modify the Supplemental Rules at any time without giving the parties prior written notice. The version governing a proceeding is determined by the filing and agreement rules in the same provision; this is not a statement that every later change automatically governs an existing case.

Supporting quotations

NAM reserves the right to modify these Supplemental Rules at any time without prior written notice to the parties.
If the parties have entered into an Arbitration or Mediation Agreement, the version of the rules in effect at the time the Demand is filed with NAM will govern the Arbitration or Mediation, unless the parties mutually agree to another version.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

The filing date generally determines which rules apply

If the parties already have an arbitration or mediation agreement, the version in effect when the Demand is filed with NAM governs, unless they mutually agree to another version. Without such an agreement, the version in effect when they file their joint submission governs.

Supporting quotations

If the parties have entered into an Arbitration or Mediation Agreement, the version of the rules in effect at the time the Demand is filed with NAM will govern the Arbitration or Mediation, unless the parties mutually agree to another version. If the parties have not entered into an Arbitration or Mediation Agreement, the version of the rules in effect at the time the parties file the joint submission with NAM will govern the proceedings.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • With an existing arbitration or mediation agreement, the parties may mutually select another version.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice

Case-specific rule changes require a written agreement and NAM acceptance

The parties may agree in writing at any time to amend NAM rules for their case, subject to NAM’s final review and acceptance. Fee schedules are an exception: only NAM, in its sole discretion, can allow their modification.

Supporting quotations

Subject to NAM’s final review and acceptance, the parties are free at any time to enter into a written agreement to amend or modify any of NAM’s rules for the purpose of their case. However, NAM’s Fee Schedules are not subject to such modification or amendment except in the sole discretion of NAM.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Fee schedule changes remain solely within NAM’s discretion.
Also annotated in the same passage (2)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice

Court remedies are preserved if a court rejects the Supplemental Rules

If a court holds provisions of these rules invalid or unenforceable, the parties have not waived their rights, privileges or remedies to bring claims, counterclaims or cross-claims in the applicable court, or to use other legal rights or remedies. This protection is tied to that court ruling.

Supporting quotations

If the provisions of these Supplemental Rules are held invalid or unenforceable by a court of law, the parties have not waived any of their rights, privileges or remedies to submit their claims, counter-claims and cross-claims to the applicable court of law or to avail themselves of any other legal rights, privileges or remedies.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

Each arbitration case needs its own Demand

Parties must initiate arbitration under the applicable rules and file a separate Demand for each case. A mass filing does not replace those individual filings with one combined Demand.

Supporting quotations

Parties shall initiate Arbitration in accordance with the applicable rules. A separate Demand must be filed for each case.

Not stated here

  • The other applicable rules governing initiation are not reproduced here.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

At 25 demands, the filing party must provide and maintain a full case list

Once the filing party has filed 25 Demands, it must give NAM and all other parties a complete list of all filed cases, in addition to filing the individual Demands. The list must include cases 1–25 and later filings, each case caption and any previously assigned NAM case number. The first 25 cases are the Initial Filing, and the filing party must supplement the list for every subsequent filing.

Supporting quotations

At such time as the filing party has filed twenty-five (25) Demands, in addition to the filing of the individual Demands, the filing party shall also submit to NAM and all other parties, a complete listing (“The List”) of all cases filed which shall include cases 1-25 as well any additional filings beyond the initial twenty-five (25) filings. The List shall include the caption of the case and any previously assigned NAM case number. The first twenty-five (25) cases filed shall hereinafter be referred to as the “Initial Filing”. It is the responsibility of the filing party to supplement The List for each and every filing subsequent to the Initial Filing.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

The response deadline can run from the procedural decision

The Respondent must file a Response with NAM and send a copy to the Claimant within 45 days of NAM’s notice that the demands have been filed and proceedings commenced. If a Procedural Arbitrator is appointed under Rule 7, the deadline is 45 days after that arbitrator’s final written determination if that is later.

Supporting quotations

The Respondent shall file a Response to the Demand(s) (hereinafter “Response”) with NAM (and send a copy to Claimant) within forty-five (45) days of the date of NAM’s notification that the Demand(s) for Arbitration has/have been filed and the arbitration proceeding(s) has/have been commenced, or in the event a Procedural Arbitrator is appointed under Rule No. 7 herein, within forty-five (45) days from the date of the final written determination of such Procedural Arbitrator, whichever is later.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The later deadline applies when a Rule 7 Procedural Arbitrator is appointed.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice

A procedural challenge has a five-business-day request window

Either party may request a Procedural Arbitrator if it disputes NAM’s mass-filing classification or believes demands breach the underlying contractual arbitration provision. The request must be filed with NAM, copied to the other parties, within five business days of NAM’s notice of filing and/or its classification decision, and before the merits arbitrators are appointed. The rule uses “and/or” for those notices without specifying a single trigger when they arrive separately.

Supporting quotations

A. In the event a party does not agree with NAM’s determination that a Demand(s) should or should not be classified as part of a Mass Filing, or believes that a Demand(s) has/have not been filed in accordance with the underlying contractual arbitration provision, and prior to the appointment of the Arbitrator(s) who will determine each case, either party, within five (5) business days of being notified by NAM that such Demand(s) has/have been filed and/or NAM’s determination of whether or not the Demand(s) is/are part of a Mass Filing, may file a Request for Appointment of a Procedural Arbitrator with NAM and copy the other parties to the matter.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The request must precede appointment of the merits arbitrators.

Not stated here

  • The text does not specify how separate filing and classification notices affect the five-business-day trigger.

Cross-references

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception

Procedural review is limited to classification and filing compliance

The Procedural Arbitrator reviews whether demands belong to a Mass Filing and which rules, procedures or requirements follow from that determination. For demands classified as mass-filed, the review can also address compliance with the underlying contractual arbitration provision. The Mass Filing definition requires at least 25 similar demands against the same or related parties with consistent or coordinated representation; simultaneous filing is unnecessary. Other issues go to the merits arbitrator once appointed.

Supporting quotations

B. The Procedural Arbitrator’s review shall be limited to: (1) whether or not a particular Demand(s) is/are part of a Mass Filing as defined herein and the applicable rules, procedures or requirements based on that determination and/or (2) if a Demand(s) is/are categorized as part of a Mass Filing, whether or not the particular Demand(s) was/were filed in accordance with the terms and conditions of the underlying contractual arbitration provision.
“Mass Filing” shall be defined as the filing of twenty-five (25) or more similar Demands for Arbitration (“Demand(s)”) against the same party or related parties and representation for the parties is consistent or coordinated across all cases. The twenty-five (25) or more Demands need not be filed simultaneously.
Any other issue(s) shall be determined by the Merits Arbitrator once appointed in accordance with Rule No. 8.

Not stated here

  • The parties’ underlying arbitration contract is not supplied here.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (3)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

One Procedural Arbitrator usually handles related multi-demand challenges

Challenges involving more than one demand against the same or related parties go to one Procedural Arbitrator. NAM may appoint multiple Procedural Arbitrators when, in its sole discretion, grouping similar or dissimilar challenges into subgroups would be more efficient.

Supporting quotations

C. With respect to a challenge(s) made concerning more than one Demand against a party/related parties, one (1) Procedural Arbitrator shall be appointed to determine the challenge(s) for all such Demands; provided that, in certain circumstances where specific challenges are similar or dissimilar and it is determined by NAM, in its sole discretion, that it would be more efficient to resolve such challenge(s) in sub-groups, multiple Procedural Arbitrators may be appointed.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • NAM may use subgroups and multiple arbitrators for efficiency.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Permission or license

The Procedural Arbitrator may permit streamlined discovery

The Procedural Arbitrator can allow streamlined discovery if needed to help decide the procedural challenge. This is discretionary and tied to that determination; other issues go to the merits arbitrator once appointed under Rule 8.

Supporting quotations

D. The Procedural Arbitrator may allow for streamlined discovery by the parties, if necessary, to assist the Procedural Arbitrator in making his/her determination. Any other issue(s) shall be determined by the Merits Arbitrator once appointed in accordance with Rule No. 8.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Discovery must be necessary to assist the procedural determination.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

The parties select a Procedural Arbitrator by striking two of three names

NAM provides three potential Procedural Arbitrators after receiving a request. The filing party strikes first and tells NAM and the responding party within five business days of panel issuance. The responding party then strikes and tells NAM and the filing party within five business days of the first strike. The remaining arbitrator is appointed. If that person cannot or will not serve, NAM issues a new three-person panel and repeats the process until an appointment is made.

Supporting quotations

E. Upon receipt of a Request for Appointment of a Procedural Arbitrator, NAM will provide a panel of three (3) potential Procedural Arbitrators to the parties. The filing party shall make the first Arbitrator strike from the panel and advise both NAM and the responding party of its strike within five (5) business days of issuance of the panel. Thereafter, the responding party shall make the second Arbitrator strike from the panel and advise both NAM and the filing party of its strike within five (5)
business days of the filing party’s strike. The remaining Arbitrator will be appointed to serve as the Procedural Arbitrator.
F. If, for any reason, the remaining Arbitrator is unable or unwilling to serve as the Procedural Arbitrator, NAM will issue another panel of three (3) potential Procedural Arbitrators and the strike process as set forth in paragraph (E) above will be repeated until such time as the Procedural Arbitrator is appointed.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

Procedural challenges use written submissions, with optional hearings

The Procedural Arbitrator decides challenges based on the parties’ written submissions, but may schedule hearings or conferences. These can be in person, by telephone or virtual.

Supporting quotations

G. The Procedural Arbitrator will render a determination of the challenge(s) based on the parties’ written submissions. However, the Procedural Arbitrator shall have the discretion and authority to schedule a hearing(s) or conference(s) on the applicable challenge(s), which hearing(s) or conference(s) may be in-person, via telephone or virtual.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

The procedural decision is final and binding; delivery requires fee payment

The Procedural Arbitrator must give a final, binding written determination with reasons. NAM forwards copies to all parties upon payment of all outstanding fees. The arbitrator’s authority ends after issuing the decision, subject to NAM’s option to reappoint that arbitrator for later demands. The Respondent’s response deadline is 45 days from the final written determination if that is later than 45 days from NAM’s commencement notice.

Supporting quotations

H. The Procedural Arbitrator will render a final and binding determination, and the reasons therefore, in writing. Copies of the determination shall be forwarded by NAM to all parties upon payment of all outstanding fees. The authority of the Procedural Arbitrator shall terminate after the issuance of his/her determination.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the event a dispute arises as to whether or not a subsequent Demand(s) should be included as part of a previously determined Mass Filing, NAM may, in its discretion, appoint the prior Procedural Arbitrator to determine said dispute or provide the parties with a panel of arbitrators for selection in accordance with paragraph (E) above.
The Respondent shall file a Response to the Demand(s) (hereinafter “Response”) with NAM (and send a copy to Claimant) within forty-five (45) days of the date of NAM’s notification that the Demand(s) for Arbitration has/have been filed and the arbitration proceeding(s) has/have been commenced, or in the event a Procedural Arbitrator is appointed under Rule No. 7 herein, within forty-five (45) days from the date of the final written determination of such Procedural Arbitrator, whichever is later.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • NAM forwards the determination only upon payment of all outstanding fees.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

NAM may reappoint the prior arbitrator for later mass-filing disputes

If a later dispute concerns whether additional demands belong to a previously determined Mass Filing, NAM may choose the prior Procedural Arbitrator or provide a selection panel using the Rule 7(E) strike process. Other procedural or administrative issues may be handled by the subsequently appointed merits arbitrator.

Supporting quotations

Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the event a dispute arises as to whether or not a subsequent Demand(s) should be included as part of a previously determined Mass Filing, NAM may, in its discretion, appoint the prior Procedural Arbitrator to determine said dispute or provide the parties with a panel of arbitrators for selection in accordance with paragraph (E) above. Any other procedural or administrative issues may be addressed by the subsequently appointed Arbitrator who will determine the merits of each case.

Cross-references

Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

Mass-filed cases normally proceed individually on their merits

Merits arbitrators are selected under the applicable rules, subject to NAM’s alternate-selection authority if that process cannot work. Unless the parties agree otherwise, each matter gets an arbitrator and proceeds individually. NAM may appoint the same arbitrator to multiple matters if selected through the applicable NAM process; that alone does not combine the cases.

Supporting quotations

The selection and appointment of the Arbitrator who will determine the merits of each matter shall be in accordance with the applicable rules governing the matter. Unless the parties agree otherwise, an Arbitrator will be appointed for each individual matter. NAM may appoint the same Arbitrator to multiple matters comprising the Mass Filing if said Arbitrator is selected pursuant to NAM’s Arbitrator Selection Process as set forth in the applicable rules. In such instance, and absent agreement of the parties otherwise, each case will proceed on an individual basis.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if, for any reason, the appointment of the Arbitrator cannot be made according to the applicable rules governing the matter, or if the agreement between the parties prohibits an Arbitrator from hearing multiple matters simultaneously such that NAM’s selection/appointment process is not viable based on the number of cases proceeding to Arbitrator appointment, the NAM Administrator may exercise his/her sole discretion in providing an alternate Arbitrator selection and appointment method.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The parties can agree otherwise about individual appointments and proceedings.

Not stated here

  • The applicable NAM selection rules are referenced but not reproduced here.

Cross-references

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Permission or license

NAM can substitute an arbitrator-selection method when the usual process is unworkable

The NAM Administrator has sole discretion to provide an alternate selection and appointment method if appointment cannot be made under the applicable rules for any reason. This also applies when a contract bars an arbitrator from hearing multiple matters simultaneously and that restriction makes NAM’s process unviable given the number of cases.

Supporting quotations

Notwithstanding the foregoing, if, for any reason, the appointment of the Arbitrator cannot be made according to the applicable rules governing the matter, or if the agreement between the parties prohibits an Arbitrator from hearing multiple matters simultaneously such that NAM’s selection/appointment process is not viable based on the number of cases proceeding to Arbitrator appointment, the NAM Administrator may exercise his/her sole discretion in providing an alternate Arbitrator selection and appointment method.

Cross-references

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure

NAM supplies three mediator choices when the contract provides for mediation

If the underlying agreement provides for mediation of each case and/or a representative number of mass-filed matters, either party may ask NAM for three potential mediators according to the contract’s time frames. Each party ranks the mediators and returns its preferences to NAM, which appoints the mediator based on those preferences.

Supporting quotations

A. In the event the parties’ underlying agreement provides for mediation of each case and/or a representative number of matters that are determined to be part of the Mass Filing, NAM will, upon request by either party, provide a list of three (3) potential mediators to the parties in accordance with the time frames set forth in the parties’ agreement. Each party will list the mediators in order of preference and return same to NAM, who will then appoint the mediator based upon the parties’ preferences.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Timing and the set of cases to be mediated depend on the underlying agreement.

Not stated here

  • The underlying contract and its mediation deadlines are not supplied here.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice

The parties may jointly choose mediation during arbitration

If their agreement does not require mediation of any mass-filed matters, the parties may mutually agree to mediate at any point in arbitration. Once notified, NAM supplies mediator choices using the three-person preference process and helps coordinate mediation. Choosing this mediation does not pause arbitration unless the parties also mutually agree to a stay.

Supporting quotations

B. In the event the parties’ agreement does NOT provide for mandatory mediation of any of the matters comprising the Mass Filing, the parties may by mutual agreement, opt to mediate at any point during the Arbitration process. Upon notice to NAM that the parties have mutually agreed to mediate, NAM will provide a list of mediators for selection of a mediator as set forth in (A) above, and will assist the parties in coordinating the mediation. The mediation will not result in a stay of the Arbitration process unless the parties mutually agree to same.
NAM will, upon request by either party, provide a list of three (3) potential mediators to the parties in accordance with the time frames set forth in the parties’ agreement. Each party will list the mediators in order of preference and return same to NAM, who will then appoint the mediator based upon the parties’ preferences.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • A pause in arbitration requires mutual agreement as well.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)