Channels is an optional one-way broadcast feature; the guidelines address channel admins
The document describes WhatsApp Channels as an optional, one-way broadcasting feature that is separate from private messaging, and it addresses its guidelines to channel admins, who "should be mindful" of them so that their updates are appropriate for a general audience. The page is marked "Last updated: February 16, 2024".
Supporting quotations
Last updated: February 16, 2024
WhatsApp Channels is an optional, one-way broadcasting feature within WhatsApp, separate from private messaging
Channel admins should be mindful of the following guidelines (these “Channels Guidelines”) so their updates are appropriate for a general audience.
Qualifications & exceptions
Concerns WhatsApp Channels, not private messaging.
"Should be mindful" is the document's wording for what it asks of admins.
Not stated here
This document does not define who counts as a channel admin as opposed to a follower.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception
Using Channels means agreeing to these guidelines and the Channels supplemental terms
The document states that by using WhatsApp Channels, "you" agree to the Channels Guidelines and to WhatsApp's Supplemental Terms of Service for WhatsApp Channels, which the document links but does not reproduce.
Admins are asked to avoid too many or low-quality updates and to give channels an informative title
Channel admins "should" be respectful of followers and avoid sending too many or low-quality updates, which could lead recipients to unfollow, and "should" give their channel a title that reflects its content and helps users make informed choices about which channels to follow. The wording is "should", not "must" or "do not", and the only consequence this passage names is that recipients could unfollow.
Supporting quotations
Channel admins should be respectful of their followers and avoid sending too many or low-quality updates, which could lead recipients to unfollow their channel.
Channel admins should provide a title for their channel that reflects the channel content and helps users make informed choices about which channels they choose to follow.
Qualifications & exceptions
Phrased as "should", an expectation rather than a listed prohibition.
Not stated here
The next sentence lets WhatsApp act against channels that violate "the following Channels Guidelines"; the document does not say whether these "should" expectations are among the guidelines enforcement applies to.
"Too many" and "low-quality" updates are not defined or measured.
Account & Service Control · Company practice
WhatsApp may take action against channels that violate the listed guidelines
WhatsApp states that it "may take action" against channels that violate the Channels Guidelines listed after this sentence. The word is "may": action is discretionary, and the kinds of action are described later under "Actions We May Take".
Supporting quotations
WhatsApp may take action against channels that violate the following Channels Guidelines:
Qualifications & exceptions
Discretionary ("may")
Applies to channels that violate the guidelines that follow.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Channels may not share illegal content or engage in illegal activity
The first listed guideline says not to share illegal content or engage in illegal activity. It states that this includes content that sexually exploits or endangers children (including child sexual abuse material) or supports violent extremist or criminal organizations or individuals, and says channels should not facilitate the exploitation of people, including through human trafficking, or share content that depicts, threatens or promotes sexual violence, sexual assault or sexual exploitation.
Supporting quotations
Do not share illegal content or engage in illegal activity.
This includes content that sexually exploits or endangers children (including child sexual abuse material), or that supports violent extremist or criminal organizations or individuals.
Channels should not facilitate the exploitation of people, including through human trafficking, or share content that depicts, threatens, or promotes sexual violence, sexual assault, or sexual exploitation.
Qualifications & exceptions
"This includes" introduces examples, not a closed list.
Not stated here
The document does not say which country's or region's law determines what is "illegal".
Channels may not share intellectual property the admin has no right to use
The same first guideline says not to share intellectual property you do not have a right to use. The document does not say here how rights are established; it points elsewhere for reporting potential intellectual property violations.
Supporting quotations
Do not share intellectual property you do not have a right to use.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to intellectual property the sharer has no right to use.
Not stated here
What counts as a "right to use" is not defined in this document.
Channels may not share content that could cause serious harm to people
The second guideline says not to share content that could cause serious harm to people. It states that this includes content that constitutes a credible threat to public or personal safety, incitement of violence, organization or coordination of violent or criminal activities, or that encourages suicide or self-injury.
Supporting quotations
Do not share content that could cause serious harm to people.
This includes content that constitutes a credible threat to public or personal safety, incitement of violence, organization or coordination of violent or criminal activities, or that encourages suicide or self-injury.
Qualifications & exceptions
"This includes" introduces examples, not a closed list.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Channels may not be used for fraud, impersonation or scams against WhatsApp or its users
The third guideline says not to engage in fraud. It states that this includes activity or content that purposefully deceives, impersonates or willfully misrepresents, or otherwise scams, defrauds or exploits WhatsApp or its users.
Supporting quotations
Do not engage in fraud.
This includes activity or content that purposefully deceives, impersonates, or willfully misrepresents or otherwise scams, defrauds, or exploits WhatsApp or our users.
Qualifications & exceptions
The listed examples are tied to purposeful or willful conduct and to WhatsApp or its users.
"This includes" introduces examples, not a closed list.
Not stated here
The sentence does not say whether "WhatsApp or our users" qualifies every verb in the list or only the last ones.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Content must be age-appropriate for all WhatsApp users, including limits on graphic and sexual imagery
The fourth guideline says to keep content age-appropriate for all WhatsApp users. As an example, channels should not include imagery that is excessively violent or graphic, or that contains sexually explicit content or pornography, "as restricted by app stores".
Supporting quotations
Keep content age-appropriate for all WhatsApp users.
For example, Channels should not include imagery that is excessively violent or graphic, or that contains sexually explicit content or pornography, as restricted by app stores.
Qualifications & exceptions
The imagery limits are introduced as an example ("For example").
Not stated here
The document does not say whether "as restricted by app stores" qualifies only the sexually explicit content and pornography or all of the imagery listed, nor which app stores or standards it means.
Channels may not be used for commercial sexual services or for offering or selling regulated or restricted goods
Under the age-appropriate guideline, channels should not be used to facilitate commercial sexual services, or to offer and/or transact in regulated or restricted goods.
Supporting quotations
Channels should not be used to facilitate commercial sexual services, or to offer and/or transact in regulated or restricted goods.
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers facilitating commercial sexual services and offering or transacting in regulated or restricted goods.
Not stated here
The document does not say which goods are "regulated or restricted", or by which law or authority.
Users are encouraged to report channels or updates that may violate the guidelines
WhatsApp encourages users to report any channel, or specific updates within a channel, that potentially violate the Channels Guidelines. It points to a linked page on how to report a channel and to a separate linked page for reporting potential intellectual property violations; neither linked page is part of this document.
Supporting quotations
We encourage users to report any channel or specific updates within a channel that potentially violate these Channels Guidelines.
You can learn more about how to report a channel on WhatsApp here.
For information on how to report potential intellectual property violations, please see here.
Qualifications & exceptions
Reports can concern a whole channel or specific updates.
Not stated here
The linked reporting instructions are not supplied in this document, so how to report is not described here.
Automated processing is central to review and makes some decisions where violations are highly likely
WhatsApp says automated data processing is central to its review process and "automates decisions for certain areas where Channels content is highly likely to violate" the guidelines.
Supporting quotations
Automated data processing is central to our review process and automates decisions for certain areas where Channels content is highly likely to violate these Channels Guidelines.
Qualifications & exceptions
Automated decisions are for "certain areas" where content is highly likely to violate the guidelines.
Not stated here
The document does not say which areas those are, what the automated decisions are, or what review, if any, follows an automated decision.
Use & Processing · Company practice
Potentially violating channels go to human reviewers, who make the final call on channels needing further review
WhatsApp says automation helps prioritize review by routing potentially violating channels to human reviewers with the right subject matter and language expertise. When a channel requires further review, automated systems send it to a human review team to make the final decision; the document says these teams are located across the globe, receive in-depth training and often specialize in certain policy areas and regions.
Supporting quotations
Automation also helps us prioritize review by routing potentially violating channels to human reviewers who have the right subject matter and language expertise, so our teams can focus on the most important cases first.
When a channel requires further review, our automated systems send it to a human review team to make the final decision.
Our human review teams are located across the globe, receive in-depth training, and often specialize in certain policy areas and regions.
Qualifications & exceptions
The human team makes the final decision when a channel "requires further review".
Not stated here
The document does not say what makes a channel require further review, or how that relates to the "certain areas" where decisions are automated.
WhatsApp reviews and responds to valid legal orders, including court orders to restrict Channels
WhatsApp states that it reviews and responds to valid legal orders from authorities in the countries where it operates, and that it may receive court orders to restrict WhatsApp Channels.
Supporting quotations
WhatsApp reviews and responds to valid legal orders from authorities in countries where we operate.
We may also receive court orders to restrict WhatsApp Channels.
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers valid legal orders from authorities in countries where WhatsApp operates.
Not stated here
The countries are not named, and this passage does not say whether affected admins are told of an order.
WhatsApp may take a range of enforcement actions, depending on the nature of the content or violation
When WhatsApp detects illegal content or a violation of its terms and policies, it states that it "may take action, including the following", depending on the nature of the content or violation. "Including" means the list is not stated to be exhaustive, and the trigger is a violation of WhatsApp's terms and policies generally, not only these guidelines. The document separately says users who disagree with a decision can appeal it from the Channels info page.
Supporting quotations
When we detect illegal content or a violation of our terms and policies, we may take action, including the following, and depending on the nature of the content or violation:
If you disagree with a decision we have made, you can appeal that decision from within your Channels info page.
Qualifications & exceptions
The action taken depends on the nature of the content or violation.
The list is introduced with "including", so it is not stated to be exhaustive.
Not stated here
This passage does not say which action applies to which kind of violation.
Update delivery can be suspended, updates removed from servers, and violating profile content removed
Among the actions WhatsApp lists are suspending further delivery of channel updates to users, removing channel updates from its servers, and removing violating content from channel profile fields, including the channel picture.
Supporting quotations
Suspending further delivery of channel updates to users
Removing channel updates from our servers
Removing violating content from channel profile fields (including the channel picture)
Qualifications & exceptions
Listed as actions WhatsApp "may" take, depending on the nature of the content or violation.
Not stated here
The list does not say whether admins are notified of these actions.
Account & Service Control · Company practice
A channel can lose verification, directory or search listing, or its invite link, or be suspended
WhatsApp also lists revoking a channel's verification, removing a channel from the in-app Directory or search results, revoking a channel's invite link, and suspending a channel.
Supporting quotations
Revoking a channel’s verification
Removing a channel from the in-app Directory or search results
Revoking a channel’s invite link
Suspending a channel
Qualifications & exceptions
Listed as actions WhatsApp "may" take, depending on the nature of the content or violation.
Not stated here
The document does not say what suspending a channel entails beyond the separate suspension of update delivery.
Account & Service Control · Company practice
Admins can be warned of violations or banned from WhatsApp's service
WhatsApp lists warning channel admins of violations of the Channels Guidelines and banning channel admin(s) from its Service as actions it may take. The document also says that if it disables an account for violating the Channels Guidelines or the Terms of Service, the user may appeal that decision as described on a linked page.
Supporting quotations
Warning channel admins of violations of these Channels Guidelines
Banning channel admin(s) from our Service, and/or
If we disable your account for a violation of these Channels Guidelines or Terms of Service, you may appeal that decision as described here.
Qualifications & exceptions
Listed as actions WhatsApp "may" take, depending on the nature of the content or violation.
Not stated here
"Our Service" is not defined in this document, so whether a ban reaches beyond Channels is not stated here.
The linked appeal instructions are not supplied in this document.
WhatsApp may report child sexual abuse material to NCMEC and/or competent authorities
WhatsApp lists reporting child sexual abuse material to NCMEC and/or competent authorities as an action it may take.
Supporting quotations
Reporting child sexual abuse material to NCMEC and/or competent authorities
Qualifications & exceptions
Concerns child sexual abuse material.
Not stated here
The document does not expand "NCMEC" or say what information accompanies a report.
Account & Service Control · Company commitment
WhatsApp says it will suspend channels whose admins repeatedly post violating content
WhatsApp states that it "will suspend" channels if admin(s) repeatedly post content that violates its terms and policies, including illegal content. It also states that the decision to suspend depends on the amount, nature and severity of the violating content and, if identifiable, the intent of the user. The document does not say how the "will" commitment and the case-by-case factors fit together.
Supporting quotations
WhatsApp will suspend channels if admin(s) repeatedly post content that violates our terms and policies, including illegal content.
The decision to suspend a channel will depend on the amount, nature, and severity of the violating content, and, if identifiable, the intent of the user.
Qualifications & exceptions
Triggered when admin(s) repeatedly post violating content.
The suspension decision depends on amount, nature and severity of the content and, if identifiable, the user's intent.
Not stated here
"Repeatedly" is not defined, and the document does not give a threshold or say how WhatsApp weighs the listed factors.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice
Additional actions may be taken as reflected in the Supplemental Terms of Service for WhatsApp Channels
WhatsApp states that it may take additional actions as reflected in the Supplemental Terms of Service for WhatsApp Channels. Those terms are referenced but not supplied here.
Supporting quotations
We may take additional actions as reflected in the Supplemental Terms of Service for WhatsApp Channels.
Qualifications & exceptions
Additional actions are those reflected in the Supplemental Terms of Service for WhatsApp Channels.
Not stated here
Which additional actions the Supplemental Terms provide is not stated in this document.
Account & Service Control · User right or choice
Admins who disagree with an enforcement decision can appeal from the Channels info page or through WhatsApp support
Where WhatsApp has taken action on a channel because it determined the channel goes against its terms or policies, including the Channels Guidelines, the document says a user who disagrees with the decision can appeal it from within the Channels info page. The user may also submit an appeal through WhatsApp support, using a linked contact page. The enforcement actions are those described in the "Actions We May Take" section.
Supporting quotations
Channels Enforcement: As described above, we may take action on channels when we determine those channels go against our terms or policies, including these Channels Guidelines.
If you disagree with a decision we have made, you can appeal that decision from within your Channels info page.
You may also submit an appeal through WhatsApp support here.
When we detect illegal content or a violation of our terms and policies, we may take action, including the following, and depending on the nature of the content or violation:
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers decisions to take action on a channel for going against WhatsApp's terms or policies.
Two routes: the Channels info page, and WhatsApp support.
Not stated here
The passage does not state a deadline for appeals, who reviews them, or how long a decision takes.
The linked WhatsApp support page is not supplied in this document.
A user whose account is disabled for violating these guidelines or the Terms of Service may appeal
If WhatsApp disables a user's account for a violation of the Channels Guidelines or the Terms of Service, the document says the user may appeal that decision "as described" on a linked page.
Supporting quotations
Account Disables: If we disable your account for a violation of these Channels Guidelines or Terms of Service, you may appeal that decision as described here.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies where an account is disabled for a violation of these guidelines or the Terms of Service.
Not stated here
The appeal steps are on a linked page that is not supplied in this document.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice
Users in the EU can take a Channels content decision to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body
If a user disagrees with a content decision WhatsApp has made on Channels and is a user in the EU, the document says they can raise that decision with a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body to resolve the issue, and links a list of such bodies.
Supporting quotations
If you disagree with a content decision we have made on Channels and are a user in the EU, you can raise that decision with a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body in order to resolve the issue.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to users in the EU.
Applies to content decisions made on Channels.
Not stated here
This document does not describe a comparable out-of-court route for users outside the EU.
The linked list of bodies is not supplied in this document.
Account & Service Control · Company commitment
WhatsApp says it will tell a user who reported content if it finds the content does not violate its terms or policies
If a user reports content posted by others and WhatsApp finds that the content does not go against its terms or policies, WhatsApp states that it will let the reporting user know. Reporting is described earlier in the document as something WhatsApp encourages users to do.
Supporting quotations
User Reports: If you report content posted by others but we find that the content does not go against our terms or policies, we will let you know.
We encourage users to report any channel or specific updates within a channel that potentially violate these Channels Guidelines.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies when a user reported content posted by others and WhatsApp finds no violation.
Not stated here
The passage does not say how or when the reporter is told.
A user can appeal a decision about a report; WhatsApp says it will reverse the enforcement if the decision was in error
In the user reports passage, the document says a user who disagrees with a decision WhatsApp has made can appeal it, and that if WhatsApp determines that its decision was in error, it "will reverse the enforcement". The passage does not say how the appeal is made, and does not explain what reversing the enforcement means when the decision being appealed was not to act on a report.
Supporting quotations
If you disagree with a decision we have made, you can appeal that decision.
If we determine that our decision was in error, we will reverse the enforcement.
Qualifications & exceptions
Appears in the passage about reporting content posted by others.
Not stated here
This passage does not state the appeal steps; other passages describe appeals from the Channels info page and through WhatsApp support, and the document does not say whether those routes apply here.
"Reverse the enforcement" is not explained for a decision not to act on a report.