Zero tolerance for child sexual exploitation; scope of Child Safety content
X says it has zero tolerance for any form of child sexual exploitation and removes certain media depicting physical child abuse. The policy treats as Child Safety content anything that contains Child Sexual Exploitation, Physical Child Abuse Media or Media of Minors in Physical Altercation, as the policy defines them below. Child and minor are used interchangeably across X policies and mean anyone under 18.
Supporting quotations
We have zero tolerance for any forms of child sexual exploitation and remove certain media depicting physical child abuse
Child Safety content is any content that contains Child Sexual Exploitation, Physical Child Abuse Media and Media of Minors in Physical Altercation, as defined below
We use the terms children and minors interchangeably in any of our policies and define them as any person under the age of 18.
Qualifications & exceptions
Physical child abuse media is removed only in 'certain' cases, not every case.
Children and minors means any person under the age of 18.
Not stated here
The document does not say how X decides which physical child abuse media is covered beyond the criteria set out in the later sections.
Content & IP Rights · Company practice
X may remove child abuse media even when shared with good intent
X encourages people to raise awareness of child exploitation, but says that posting media of children experiencing sexual abuse or certain types of physical abuse can revictimize them and normalize violence against children. X says it may remove such content even if it was shared with good intent, to express outrage or in a humoristic context, because protecting minors takes priority over the context of sharing. The wording is 'may remove', so removal is X's discretion, and the policy later describes limited exceptions.
Supporting quotations
even when shared with the intent to bring awareness or justice, to express outrage or sharing content in a humoristic context
When this content is shared on >x<, we may remove it even if it was shared with good intent.
Our priority is to protect minors from physical and psychological harm irrespective of the context in which the content may be shared.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to media of children experiencing sexual abuse or certain types of physical abuse.
'May remove': X's discretion, not an automatic outcome.
The saved page shows a heading reading May 2024 above a repeat of the policy summary. The page does not say whether it is an effective date, a last-updated date or a revision label.
Supporting quotations
May 2024
Not stated here
Whether May 2024 is an effective date, a last-updated date or a revision label is not stated.
No other stated date is given in the saved page.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Content depicting or promoting child sexual exploitation is prohibited, including AI-generated media
X has zero tolerance for material that features or promotes child sexual exploitation. The policy lists real media, text, illustrated or computer-generated media, including generative AI media, and says this applies regardless of intent. X states that viewing, sharing, linking or engaging with such material contributes to revictimizing the depicted children. It also covers content that contributes to victimization through promoting or glorifying child sexual exploitation.
Supporting quotations
has zero tolerance towards any material that features or promotes child sexual exploitation
This may include real media, text, illustrated, or computer-generated media - including generative AI media.
Regardless of the intent, anyone viewing, sharing, linking, or engaging with any kind of child sexual exploitation material contributes to the re-victimization of the depicted children
This also applies to content that may further contribute to victimization of children through the promotion or glorification of child sexual exploitation.
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers real, text, illustrated and computer-generated media, including generative AI media.
'Regardless of the intent'; the policy still describes limited exceptions elsewhere.
Not stated here
The first sentence of the quoted block begins 'x<' in the saved text; the extraction appears to have cut the opening of the sentence.
Sharing, requesting, linking to or engaging with child sexual exploitation content is not allowed
Any content that depicts or promotes child sexual exploitation is strictly prohibited on X. The prohibition includes, but is not limited to, directly or indirectly sharing, requesting, linking to, engaging with (such as liking, reposting or following accounts that distribute), expressing a desire for, or describing the content. The listed items are depictions of a child in sexually explicit or suggestive acts (including edits such as obscuring faces or body parts), sexualized commentary about or directed at a known or unknown minor, links to third-party sites hosting such material, and fantasies about or promotion of child sexual exploitation.
Supporting quotations
Any content that depicts or promotes child sexual exploitation is strictly prohibited on >x<.
directly or indirectly sharing, requesting, linking to, engaging with (such as liking or reposting, or following accounts that distribute), expressing a desire for, or describing:
depictions of a child engaging in sexually explicit or suggestive acts, which may include edits of such media, such as obscuring faces or body parts;
sexualized commentaries about or directed at a known (or unknown) minor;
links to third-party sites that host child sexual exploitation materials of any kind; and
fantasies about or promoting engagement in child sexual exploitation.
Qualifications & exceptions
'Includes, but is not limited to': the list is not exhaustive.
Covers engaging such as liking, reposting or following accounts that distribute.
Edited media such as obscured faces or body parts is covered.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Additional prohibitions: grooming, solicitation, naming alleged victims and normalizing attraction to minors
Beyond the list above, X prohibits identifying alleged victims of childhood sexual exploitation by name or image; promoting or normalizing sexual attraction to minors as an identity or sexual orientation; sending sexually explicit media to a child or trying to engage a child in a sexually explicit conversation; trying to obtain sexually explicit media from a child or trying to engage a child in sexual activity through blackmail or other incentives; recruiting, advertising or expressing interest in a commercial sex act involving a child, or in harboring or transporting a child for sexual purposes; and threatening to share, or asking others to share, sexual media of minors, including self-generated sexual media, particularly when blackmail or bounty tactics are involved.
Supporting quotations
Additionally, we prohibit any of the following:
identifying alleged victims of childhood sexual exploitation by name or image;
promoting or normalizing sexual attraction to minors as a form of identity or sexual orientation;
sending sexually explicit media to a child, or engaging or trying to engage a child in a sexually explicit conversation;
trying to obtain sexually explicit media from a child, or trying to engage a child in sexual activity through blackmail or other incentives;
recruiting, advertising or expressing an interest in a commercial sex act involving a child, or in harboring and/or transporting a child for sexual purposes; and
threatening to share, or requesting that others share sexual media of minors, including self-generated sexual media of minors, particularly when engaging in blackmail or bounty tactics.
Qualifications & exceptions
The blackmail or bounty reference is 'particularly' emphasized; the prohibition on threatening to share or requesting sexual media of minors is not limited to those tactics.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Very limited exceptions where there is low risk of direct harm to a minor
X says it will make very limited exceptions to content related to child sexual exploitation only where there is a low risk of direct harm to the minor or minors. The listed exceptions are discussion that does not promote or glorify child sexual exploitation or identify the potential victim; victims sharing their stories without explicit details or media; conversations about help-seeking behavior of people who may struggle with an attraction to minors; and advocacy against illegal or harmful activity involving minors, provided there is no sharing of or linking to child sexual exploitation material.
Supporting quotations
We will make very limited exceptions to content related to child sexual exploitation only where there is a low risk of direct harm to the minor(s):
discussion related to child sexual exploitation that does not promote or glorify child sexual exploitation in any way or identify the potential victim;
victims sharing their stories, provided they do not contain explicit details or media;
conversations about help-seeking behavior of individuals who may struggle with an attraction to minors; and
advocacy against illegal or harmful activity involving minors, provided there is no sharing of, or linking to any material featuring child sexual exploitation.
Qualifications & exceptions
Only where there is a low risk of direct harm to the minor(s).
Victim stories must not contain explicit details or media.
Advocacy must not share or link to child sexual exploitation material.
Not stated here
The policy does not say who decides whether risk is low or what test X applies.
Violations of the Child Sexual Exploitation policy usually lead to immediate permanent suspension
For violations of the Child Sexual Exploitation policy, X says that in the majority of cases users will be immediately and permanently suspended. For certain violations, X may instead require post removal, for example by asking someone to remove the violating content, and subsequent violations may lead to account suspension.
Supporting quotations
in the majority of cases, users will be immediately and permanently suspended;
for certain violations, we may instead require post removal. For example, we may ask someone to remove the violating content. Subsequent violations may lead to account suspension.
Qualifications & exceptions
'In the majority of cases' suspension is immediate and permanent; other cases may instead get a post-removal requirement.
Post removal applies only to 'certain violations'.
Not stated here
The policy does not say which violations get post removal rather than suspension.
Sharing & Disclosure · Company practice
X reports accounts sharing child sexual exploitation content to NCMEC
When X is made aware of content depicting or promoting child sexual exploitation, including links to third-party sites where it can be accessed, X says the accounts sharing the content will be reported to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC). The policy does not say what information about the account is included in the report.
Supporting quotations
when we’re made aware of content depicting or promoting child sexual exploitation, including links to third party sites where this content can be accessed, the accounts sharing this content will be reported to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC)
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies when X is made aware of the content.
Covers links to third-party sites where the content can be accessed.
Not stated here
What account information is included in a report to NCMEC is not stated.
Content & IP Rights · Company practice
X removes most media depicting physical child abuse, even if shared to raise awareness
To prevent revictimization or normalization of violence against children, X says it will remove most instances of media depicting physical child abuse, even if shared to raise awareness or express outrage. The earlier statement that X may remove child abuse media even when shared with good intent applies here too; the section then lists factors and limited exceptions.
Supporting quotations
we will remove most instances of media depicting physical child abuse, even if shared to raise awareness or express outrage.
we may remove it even if it was shared with good intent
Qualifications & exceptions
'Most instances', not all; exceptions are listed under Restricted reach.
Applies to media depicting physical child abuse.
Not stated here
The policy does not say how X decides which instances are not removed beyond the listed factors and exceptions.
X weighs the child's clothing, severity of harm and the sharing context for physical abuse media
When deciding what to do with media depicting physical child abuse, X says it considers whether the child is nude, partially clothed or fully clothed, the severity of harm the child is experiencing, and whether the media was shared with abusive, non-abusive or newsworthy context. With those criteria, X says it is more likely to remove media where the child is nude and experiencing any type of harm, media shared with abusive context, and media where the child is experiencing moderate or major harm.
Supporting quotations
When assessing the best course of action to take, we consider:
whether the child is nude, partially clothed, or fully clothed;
the severity of harm the child is experiencing; and
whether the media was shared with abusive, non-abusive, or newsworthy context.
we are more likely to remove any media:
where the child is nude and experiencing any type of harm;
shared with abusive context; and
where the child is experiencing moderate or major harm.
Qualifications & exceptions
'More likely to remove': a tendency, not a fixed rule.
The factors guide X's choice of action; the policy does not give weights.
Not stated here
How the factors are weighed against each other is not stated.
The policy does not define moderate or major harm.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Limited exceptions for physical abuse media: rescue, identifying perpetrators and news organizations
X says it will make limited exceptions for media depicting physical child abuse in certain circumstances, such as when the media is shared to identify the child in order to rescue them from the abusive situation or to identify the perpetrator, and when it is shared by news organizations. If X decides to allow the media, it says it will require it to be placed behind its Graphic Content warning.
Supporting quotations
Restricted reach
We will make limited exceptions to media depicting physical child abuse in certain circumstances, such as:
when the media is being shared to identify the child in order to rescue them from the abusive situation, or identify the perpetrator; and
when the media is being shared by news organizations.
If we decide to allow this media on the platform, we will require it to be placed behind our Graphic Content warning.
Qualifications & exceptions
'Such as': the examples may not be the only circumstances.
Allowed media must go behind the Graphic Content warning.
Not stated here
The policy does not say who qualifies as a news organization or how X confirms a rescue or identification purpose.
Enforcement for physical child abuse media: warning, removal with read-only period, or suspension
For violations of the Physical Child Abuse Media policy, X says it may make the content less visible by applying a content warning or by requiring post removal. For removal, X gives the example of asking someone to remove the content and serve a period of time in read-only mode before they can post again; subsequent violations may lead to account suspension. X may also suspend accounts whose sole purpose appears to be to engage in the prohibited behavior.
Supporting quotations
For violations of our Physical Child Abuse Media policy, we may:
Make the content less visible on >x< by:
applying a content warning; or
requiring post removal. For example, we may ask someone to remove the violating content and serve a period of time in read-only mode before they can post again. Subsequent violations may lead to account suspension.
Suspend accounts whose sole purpose appears to be to engage in the types of behavior prohibited above.
Qualifications & exceptions
'May': the actions are options available to X.
Account suspension for subsequent violations is stated as 'may lead to'.
Suspension for sole-purpose accounts depends on the sole purpose 'appearing' to be the prohibited behavior.
Not stated here
The length of the read-only period is not stated.
The policy does not say when a warning applies rather than removal.
Content & IP Rights · Company practice
X weighs context, minor's report and graphic content for media of minors in physical altercations
X says it aims to protect the wellbeing of minors involved in physical altercations, whether victim or aggressor, while balancing the need to raise awareness. When assessing the best course of action, X says it may consider whether the content is shared with an abusive or non-abusive context, whether it has received a report from the minor or an authorized representative, and whether the content is excessively graphic.
Supporting quotations
We aim to protect the wellbeing of minors involved in physical altercation, regardless of their status (i.e victim or aggressor), while balancing the need to raise awareness of these issues.
we may consider whether:
the content is shared with an abusive or non-abusive context;
we have received a report from the minor or an authorized representative; and
the content is excessively graphic.
Qualifications & exceptions
'May consider': the factors are not stated to be required or exhaustive.
The policy covers minors whether victim or aggressor.
Not stated here
How the factors are weighed is not stated.
The policy does not define excessively graphic or who counts as an authorized representative.
Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception
Limited exception for media of minors in physical altercations shared by news organizations
X says it will make limited exceptions for media depicting children in physical altercation in certain circumstances, such as when the media is shared by news organizations. If X decides to allow the media, it says it may require it to be placed behind a content warning. This differs from physical child abuse media, where the policy says X will require the Graphic Content warning.
Supporting quotations
Restricted reach
We will make limited exceptions to media depicting children in physical altercation in certain circumstances, such as when the media is being shared by news organizations. If we decide to allow this media on the platform, we may require it to be placed behind a content warning.
Qualifications & exceptions
'Such as': news organizations is an example, not a stated limit.
Content warning is something X 'may' require.
Not stated here
The policy does not say who counts as a news organization.
Enforcement for media of minors in physical altercations: post removal on a report; other policies may apply
For violations of the Media of Minors in Physical Altercation policy, X says it may require post removal upon receiving a report from the minor or an authorized representative, for example by asking someone to remove the content and serve a period of time in read-only mode before they can post again; subsequent violations may lead to account suspension. X also says that Abusive Behavior policies may apply to content abusive toward the victim, and Sensitive Media policies may apply to Graphic content or Gratuitous Gore. Those other policies are not part of the supplied document.
Supporting quotations
We may require post removal upon receiving a report from the minor or an authorized representative. For example, we may ask someone to remove the violating content and serve a period of time in read-only mode before they can post again. Subsequent violations may lead to account suspension;
when sharing content that is abusive towards the victim Abusive Behavior policies may apply; and
when sharing content that is Graphic or includes Gratuitous Gore, our Sensitive Media policies may apply.
Qualifications & exceptions
Post removal is tied to a report from the minor or an authorized representative.
'May': the actions are options available to X.
Not stated here
The Abusive Behavior and Sensitive Media policies are referenced but their text is not supplied.
The length of the read-only period is not stated.
Whether X acts without a report from the minor or representative is not stated in this section.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice
Anyone can report violations without an X account; contact police if a child is in immediate danger
Anyone can report violations of this policy through X's in-app reporting flow or its Help Center form, and an X account is not needed to report. If you believe a child is at immediate risk of harm or death, the policy says to contact local law enforcement. After reporting possible Child Sexual Exploitation violations to X, you can also notify NCMEC through its CyberTipline or by phone.
Supporting quotations
Anyone can report violations of this policy using our dedicated in-app reporting flow or via our Help Center. An >x< account is not needed to report potential violations.
If you believe a child is at immediate risk of harm or death, please reach out to your local law enforcement.
after reporting potential violations of our Child Sexual Exploitation policy to us, you can also notify the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) by using their CyberTipline portal or calling 1-800-843-5678.
Qualifications & exceptions
The NCMEC option is for possible violations of the Child Sexual Exploitation policy, after reporting to X.
Contacting law enforcement is for a child at immediate risk of harm or death.
Not stated here
The policy does not say what X does with reports or how quickly it responds.
Account & Service Control · User right or choice
You can submit an appeal if you believe X made a mistake
If you believe X made a mistake, the policy says you can submit an appeal through the linked appeals form. The policy does not say who may appeal, the time limit or how X decides appeals.
The appeals process, timing and standard are not described in this document; the form page is not supplied.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Context
X says it seeks input from partner organizations and links an update on its work
X says it is constantly seeking feedback and input from trusted organizations aligned with the mission to combat online child sexual exploitation, and links to a blog post about its partnerships. The blog post is not part of the supplied document and is not analyzed here.
Supporting quotations
We are constantly seeking feedback and input from trusted organizations that are aligned in the mission to combat online child sexual exploitation.
Not stated here
Which organizations X works with and what the linked blog update says are not supplied.