Violent and hateful entities policy

X · Official agreement

Read the agreement

10 of 11 cards in Account & Service Control

Account & Service Control · Restriction or exception

You may not affiliate with or promote violent and hateful entities

X says there is no place on X for violent and hateful entities, and that under this policy you can't affiliate with or promote their activities. The ban covers terrorist organizations, violent extremist groups, perpetrators of violent attacks and individuals who affiliate with and promote their illicit activities, and the list is described as not limited to those groups. It also bars threatening terrorism or violent extremism. The policy says the concern is that the violence and hate these entities engage in or promote jeopardizes the physical safety of those targeted. Which entities X treats as violent or hateful is decided by X; no list of named entities is given in this document.

Supporting quotations

There is no place on >x< for violent and hateful entities, including (but not limited to) terrorist organizations, violent extremist groups, perpetrators of violent attacks, or individuals who affiliate with and promote their illicit activities.
The violence and hate these entities engage in and/or promote jeopardizes the physical safety of those targeted.
You may not threaten terrorism and/or violent extremism, nor promote violent and hateful entities.
Under this policy, you can’t affiliate with or promote the activities of violent and hateful entities.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The named groups are examples: "including (but not limited to)".
  • Applies to affiliating with or promoting the entities' activities, as well as threatening terrorism or violent extremism.

Not stated here

  • The policy gives no list of named entities and does not say how X decides that an entity is violent or hateful.
  • The linked page on perpetrators of violent attacks is not supplied here, so what it adds to the list of covered entities is not part of this analysis.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Account & Service Control · Context

Violent entities are groups that target people or essential infrastructure

The policy defines violent entities as those that deliberately target humans or essential infrastructure with physical violence or violent rhetoric as a means to further their cause. The definition names terrorist organizations, violent extremist groups and perpetrators of violent attacks, and says the list is not limited to those examples.

Supporting quotations

Violent entities are those that deliberately target humans or essential infrastructure with physical violence and/or violent rhetoric as a means to further their cause.
These include, but are not limited to, terrorist organizations, violent extremist groups, and perpetrators of violent attacks.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Requires deliberate targeting of humans or essential infrastructure.
  • The means is physical violence and/or violent rhetoric, used to further their cause.

Not stated here

  • The linked page on perpetrators of violent attacks is not supplied here, so its criteria are not part of this analysis.

Account & Service Control · Context

Hateful entities are those that systematically promote hateful conduct

The policy defines hateful entities as those that have systematically and intentionally promoted, supported or advocated for hateful conduct. It describes hateful conduct as including promoting violence or engaging in targeted harassment towards a protected category. The full meaning of hateful conduct is in a separate linked policy that is not supplied here.

Supporting quotations

Hateful entities are those that have systematically and intentionally promoted, supported and/or advocated for hateful conduct, which includes promoting violence or engaging in targeted harassment towards a protected category.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Requires conduct that is systematic and intentional.
  • Hateful conduct is described as including promoting violence or targeted harassment towards a protected category; "includes" does not say the description is complete.

Not stated here

  • The linked hateful conduct policy and its list of protected categories are not supplied here.

Account & Service Control · Restriction or exception

Examples of violating activity: violence, recruiting, and propaganda or services

The policy gives examples of content that violates it. They are doing the following on behalf of, indirectly, or directly for a violent or hateful entity: engaging in or promoting violent acts, or recruiting, or providing or distributing services (such as media or propaganda) to further the entity's stated goals. The examples are described as not limited to these.

Supporting quotations

Examples of the types of content that violate this policy include, but are not limited to, doing the following on behalf of, indirectly, or directly for a violent or hateful entity:
Engaging in or promoting violent acts
Recruiting, or providing or distributing services (such as media/propaganda) to further stated goals

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The activity must be done on behalf of, indirectly, or directly for a violent or hateful entity.
  • The examples are "not limited to" the two listed.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Account & Service Control · Restriction or exception

X may make limited exceptions for reformed, peace-process or governmental entities

X says it may make limited exceptions for violent and hateful entities if it determines one of three things: the entity has reformed or denounced its violence or hate-based purpose, the entity is currently engaged in a peaceful resolution process, or the entity is a state or governmental entity, including those with representatives elected to public office. The wording is "may", so an exception is X's choice, not a right, and it is described as limited. The page's opening summary mentions only the reformed and peaceful-resolution cases, while the body also lists governmental entities. The source does not say whether the three conditions are alternatives or must all be met.

Supporting quotations

Users may not promote, recruit for, or share propaganda from such groups unless they've reformed or engaged in peaceful resolution.
We may make limited exceptions for violent and hateful entities if we can determine the following:
They have reformed or denounced their violence and/or hate-based purpose.
They are currently engaged in a peaceful resolution process.
They are state or governmental entities, including those that have representatives elected to public office.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Exceptions are discretionary ("may") and "limited".
  • Applies only if X can determine that the condition is met.

Not stated here

  • The source does not say whether the three listed conditions are alternatives or must all apply; the list is introduced without "or" or "and".
  • The policy does not say how X makes these determinations.

Account & Service Control · Restriction or exception

Discussing these entities for educational, documentary or newsworthy purposes is allowed

The policy says that discussions of violent and hateful entities for clearly educational, documentary or newsworthy purposes are not a violation of this policy. Unlike the limited exceptions for entities, this sentence is stated as a plain rule, not as something X "may" allow. The qualifier is that the purpose must be clearly educational, documentary or newsworthy.

Supporting quotations

Additionally, any discussions of violent and hateful entities for clearly educational, documentary, and/or newsworthy purposes is not a violation of this policy.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to discussions of the entities, not to affiliating with or promoting them.
  • The purpose must be "clearly" educational, documentary and/or newsworthy.

Not stated here

  • The policy does not say who decides whether a purpose is clearly educational, documentary or newsworthy.

Account & Service Control · User right or choice

Anyone can report potential violations, with or without an X account

The policy says anyone can report potential violations of it, whether or not they have an X account.

Supporting quotations

Anyone can report potential violations of this policy, whether they have an >x< account or not.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Covers potential violations of this policy only.

Account & Service Control · Procedure

Reporting steps in the iOS app and on desktop

The policy describes reporting in two places. In the iOS app, you select Report Account from the icon, select Violent & hateful entities, and submit your report. On desktop, the steps listed are the same three. The source calls this reporting content "for review"; it does not say what review follows or whether you are told the result.

Supporting quotations

You can report this content for review in-app on iOS as follows:
Select Report Account from the icon.
Select Violent & hateful entities.
Submit your report.
You can report this content for review via desktop as follows:
Select Report Account from the icon.
Select Violent & hateful entities.
Submit your report.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • In-app steps are described for iOS only; the source does not describe other apps.
  • The steps start from "the icon", which the source does not identify further.

Not stated here

  • The source does not say which icon is meant, what review follows a report, or whether the reporter is told the outcome.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

Accounts found in violation are immediately and permanently suspended

X says it will immediately and permanently suspend any account that it determines to be in violation of this policy. No lesser step is described in this policy. If you believe your account was suspended in error, the policy links to an appeal form. The suspension depends on X's own determination of a violation.

Supporting quotations

We will immediately and permanently suspend any account that we determine to be in violation of this policy.
If you believe that your account was suspended in error, you can submit an appeal.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to an account X determines to be in violation of this policy.
  • Suspension is described as immediate and permanent.

Not stated here

  • The linked appeal form and its process are not supplied here, so how an appeal works or how long it takes is unknown.
  • The linked enforcement options page is not supplied, so any other enforcement steps are unknown.