How we enforce our rules

X · Official agreement

Read the agreement

16 of 16 cards

Account & Service Control · Company practice

X may act on a piece of content, an account, or both

When X takes enforcement action, it may act on a specific piece of content (such as one post or Direct Message), on an account, or use a combination. The page gives two reasons: the behavior violates the X Rules, or X is responding to a valid legal request from an authorized entity in a given country. The page presents the actions below as examples ("some of the enforcement actions that we may take"), not a complete list.

Supporting quotations

uses a range of enforcement actions at the post, direct message, and account levels
we may do so either on a specific piece of content (e.g., an individual post or Direct Message), on an account, or employ a combination of these options
In some instances, this is because the behavior violates the >x< Rules. Other times, it may be in response to a valid legal request from an authorized entity in a given country.
Below are some of the enforcement actions that we may take.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The listed actions are examples, not a full list.
  • Legal-request actions depend on the request being valid and from an authorized entity in a given country.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say which entities count as authorized or how X decides a legal request is valid.
  • The linked X Rules document's text is not supplied here, so this card cannot say what the Rules prohibit.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

Post-level action covers posts that share or reproduce violating posts

X takes post-level action when a specific post violates the X Rules. This includes posts that share or reproduce other posts by posting screenshots, quote-posting, or sharing post URLs, where the shared post violates the Rules.

Supporting quotations

We take action at the post level when a specific post violates the >x< Rules, including posts that share or reproduce other posts by posting screenshots, quote-posting, or sharing post URLs that violate our Rules.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies when a specific post violates the X Rules, including screenshots, quote-posts or URLs of violating posts.

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

X may limit a violating post's reach in several ways

Where appropriate, X says it will restrict the reach of posts that violate its policies and create a negative experience for other users, making the post less discoverable. The page lists what this can include: excluding the post from search results, trends and recommended notifications; removing it from the For you and Following timelines; restricting its discoverability to the author's profile; downranking it in replies; and restricting Likes, replies, Reposts, Quote posts, bookmarks, share, pin to profile, or Edit post.

Supporting quotations

A few of the ways in which we might take action at the post level include:
Where appropriate, we will restrict the reach of posts that violate our policies and create a negative experience for other users by making the post less discoverable on >x<. This can include:
Excluding the post from search results, trends, and recommended notifications
Removing the post from the For you and Following timelines
Restricting the post’s discoverability to the author’s profile
Downranking the post in replies
Restricting Likes, replies, Reposts, Quote posts, bookmarks, share, pin to profile, or Edit post

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies "where appropriate" to posts that violate policies and create a negative experience for other users.
  • The list says what limiting visibility "can include"; it is not stated to be complete.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how X decides when limiting is appropriate.

Content & IP Rights · User right or choice

Limited posts receive labels, and authors can appeal the label

Under the heading "Excluding the post from having ads adjacent to it", the page states that starting in April 2023, posts identified as violating the Rules will begin to receive labels telling both authors and viewers that X limited the post's visibility. Authors will be able to submit an appeal on the label if they think X incorrectly limited the post's visibility. The paragraph does not itself describe how ads are kept away from such posts.

Supporting quotations

Excluding the post from having ads adjacent to it: Starting in April 2023, posts identified as violating our Rules will begin to receive labels informing both post authors and viewers that we limited the post’s visibility.
Authors will be able to submit an appeal on the label if they think we incorrectly limited their post’s visibility.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Labels begin starting in April 2023 for posts identified as violating the Rules.
  • Appeal is available to authors who think the limit was incorrect.

Not stated here

  • The paragraph under the heading about ads adjacent to a post does not state how ad exclusion works.
  • The page does not say whether the labeling and appeal described as starting in April 2023 are now in effect.

Content & IP Rights · Procedure

X may require a violator to remove a severely violating post before posting again

When X determines a post violated the X Rules and the violation is severe enough to warrant removal, it will require the violator to remove the post before they can post again. The violator must either remove the post or appeal the removal request if they believe X made an error. During this process the post is hidden from public view with a notice.

Supporting quotations

When we determine that a post violated the >x< Rules and the violation is severe enough to warrant post removal, we will require the violator to remove it before they can post again.
They will need to go through the process of removing the violating post or appealing our removal request if they believe we made an error.
The post will be hidden from public view with a notice during this process.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies when the violation is severe enough to warrant post removal.
  • The violator cannot post again until the post is removed (or, per the page, the removal request is appealed).

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how long an appeal takes or whether the violator may post while an appeal is pending.
  • The linked appeals form and notice pages are not supplied here, so this card cannot say how appeals or notices work.

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

X may label posts with misleading or disputed information

If X determines a post contains misleading or disputed information, under its policies, that could potentially lead to harm, it may add a label to provide context and additional information. In these cases Community Notes may also be visible on the post.

Supporting quotations

If we determine a post contains misleading or disputed information per our policies that could potentially lead to harm, we may add a label to the content to provide context and additional information to users.
In these cases, Community Notes may also be visible on posts to provide additional context

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to misleading or disputed information "per our policies" that could potentially lead to harm.

Not stated here

  • The linked policies defining misleading or disputed information are not part of the supplied source.

Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception

A rule-violating post may stay up behind a notice under a public interest exception

X may decide it is in the public interest for a post that would otherwise violate its rules to stay accessible. When it does, X places the post behind a notice and limits its visibility.

Supporting quotations

We may determine that it is in the public interest for a post that would otherwise be in violation of our rules to remain accessible on our service.
we will place the post behind a notice and limit its visibility

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies only where X determines remaining accessible is in the public interest.
  • The post is placed behind a notice and its visibility is limited.

Not stated here

  • The page does not define the public interest standard here; it points to a separate page.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

Reported violators are stopped from messaging the reporter, and the conversation resumes if the reporter writes again

In a private Direct Message conversation, when a participant reports the other account, X will stop the reported account from sending messages to the reporter, and the conversation is removed from the reporter's inbox. If the reporter decides to keep sending Direct Messages to the violator, the conversation resumes.

Supporting quotations

In a private Direct Message conversation, when a participant reports the other account, we will stop the violator from sending messages to the account who reported them.
The conversation will also be removed from the reporter's inbox.
if the reporter decides to continue to send Direct Messages to the violator, the conversation will resume

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to a private Direct Message conversation after one participant reports the other.
  • The conversation resumes if the reporter continues to send Direct Messages to the violator.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

A violating group Direct Message may be placed behind a notice

In a group Direct Message conversation, X may place a violating Direct Message behind a notice so that no one else in the group can see it again.

Supporting quotations

In a group Direct Message conversation, the violating Direct Message may be placed behind a notice to ensure no one else in the group can see it again.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to group Direct Message conversations.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

X suspends accounts for repeated violations or specific high-risk violations

X takes action to suspend an account if it determines the user has engaged in repeated violations of its policies and/or violated specific policies that cause significant risk to X or pose a threat to its users. The page gives examples: illegal content, attempts to manipulate the platform or spam users, and using the platform to incite violence for risk to X; and fraud, user privacy violations, violent threats and targeted harassment for threats to users. The examples are introduced with "i.e." and end with "etc.", so the page does not make them an exhaustive list.

Supporting quotations

We take action to suspend an account if we determine that a user has engaged in repeated violations of our policies and/or violated specific policies that cause significant risk to >x< (i.e. posting illegal content, attempts to manipulate our platform or spam users, using our platform to incite violence, etc.) or pose a threat to our users (fraud, user privacy violations, violent threats, targeted harassment, etc.).

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies if X determines repeated violations and/or violation of specific policies that cause significant risk to X or pose a threat to users.
  • Listed examples are not stated to be complete.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how many violations count as repeated.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

X may place an account in read-only mode

X may temporarily limit an account's ability to post, Repost, or Like. The user can read their timelines and can send Direct Messages only to their followers.

Supporting quotations

We may temporarily limit an account’s ability to post, Repost, or Like.
The user can read their timelines and will only be able to send Direct Messages to their followers.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The limit is temporary.
  • While limited, Direct Messages can be sent only to the user's followers.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say what triggers read-only mode or how long it lasts.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

X may require phone or email verification, and a locked account is removed from counts

X may require an account owner to verify ownership with a phone number or email address. When an account has been locked pending completion of a challenge, such as being required to provide a phone number, it is removed from follower counts, Reposts, and Likes.

Supporting quotations

We may require an account owner to verify ownership with a phone number or email address.
when an account has been locked pending completion of a challenge (such as being required to provide a phone number), it is removed from follower counts, Reposts, and Likes

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The removal from follower counts, Reposts and Likes applies while an account is locked pending completion of a challenge.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say whether the removal is reversed once the challenge is completed.

Account & Service Control · User right or choice

Users can appeal an account suspension

Users can appeal account suspensions if they believe X made an error. They can appeal through the platform interface or by filing a report.

Supporting quotations

Users can appeal account suspensions if they believe we made an error. They can do this through the platform interface or by filing a report.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to users who believe X made an error.

Not stated here

  • The page does not state how X handles appeals or how long they take.

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

X may put sensitive media behind a click-through warning

Under the heading for actions against non-violating content, X says it may place some forms of sensitive media, such as adult content or graphic violence, behind an interstitial. The interstitial advises viewers that they will see sensitive media if they click through. This is listed as an action against content that is not necessarily in violation of the rules.

Supporting quotations

Actions we may take against non-violating content
We may place some forms of sensitive media like adult content or graphic violence behind an interstitial advising viewers to be aware that they will see sensitive media if they click through.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Listed under actions X may take against non-violating content.
  • Applies to "some forms" of sensitive media such as adult content or graphic violence.

Not stated here

  • The linked sensitive media page's text is not supplied here, so this card cannot say which media X treats as sensitive beyond the examples named.

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

X restricts sensitive media for viewers under 18 or without a birth date

X says it restricts views of specific forms of sensitive media, such as adult content, for viewers who are under 18 or who do not include a birth date on their profile, using interstitials. This is listed under actions X may take against non-violating content.

Supporting quotations

Actions we may take against non-violating content
We restrict views of specific forms of sensitive media such as adult content for viewers who are under 18 or viewers who do not include a birth date on their profile

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to viewers who are under 18 or whose profile has no birth date.
  • Applies to "specific forms" of sensitive media such as adult content.
  • Listed under actions X may take against non-violating content.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say which forms of sensitive media besides adult content are covered.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice

X may withhold content in a country on a valid, properly scoped request

X may withhold access to certain content in a particular country if it receives a valid and properly scoped request from an authorized entity in that country. This matches the earlier statement that enforcement may respond to a valid legal request from an authorized entity in a given country. It is listed under actions X may take against non-violating content.

Supporting quotations

Actions we may take against non-violating content
We may withhold access to certain content in a particular country if we receive a valid and properly scoped request from an authorized entity in that country.
Other times, it may be in response to a valid legal request from an authorized entity in a given country.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies only to a valid and properly scoped request from an authorized entity in that country.
  • Access is withheld in a particular country.

Not stated here

  • The linked country-withheld-content page is not supplied here, so this card cannot say how X notifies users or decides a request is valid and properly scoped.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)