Our approach to policy development and enforcement philosophy

X · Official agreement

Read the agreement

13 of 13 cards

Content & IP Rights · Company commitment

Offensive views are welcome; harassment, threats and silencing by fear are not

The page says the service reflects real conversations, which can include perspectives others find offensive, controversial or bigoted. Everyone is welcome to express themselves, but the page states the service will not tolerate behavior that harasses, threatens, or uses fear to silence other people's voices. This is a statement of the publisher's general stance; the specific rules and what counts as a violation are set out in the X Rules, which this page links but does not include.

Supporting quotations

While we welcome everyone to express themselves on our service, we will not tolerate behavior that harasses, threatens, or uses fear to silence the voices of others.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The line is drawn at behavior that harasses, threatens, or uses fear to silence others, not at offensive viewpoints as such.
  • The specific rules are in the linked X Rules, which are not part of this saved page.

Not stated here

  • What the X Rules define as harassment, threats or silencing through fear is not stated on this page.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company commitment

X says it enforces the X Rules with uniform consistency

The page says the X Rules exist to help everyone feel safe expressing their beliefs, and that the service strives to enforce them with uniform consistency. The wording is an aim (strives), not a guarantee of identical outcomes. The page points to separate articles for the Rules and for the different enforcement actions; their text is not supplied here.

Supporting quotations

in place to help ensure everyone feels safe expressing their beliefs and we strive to enforce them with uniform consistency

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Stated as an effort (strive), not a guarantee.
  • The Rules and the list of enforcement actions are in linked pages that are not part of this saved page.

Not stated here

  • The content of the linked X Rules and the linked page on different enforcement actions is not available in this document.

Cross-references

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice

New policies and policy changes require research, public wording and reviewer guidance

The page describes what creating a new policy or changing one involves: in-depth research on trends in online behavior, clear external language that sets expectations for what is allowed, and enforcement guidance for reviewers that can be scaled across millions of posts. It describes the publisher's process; it does not create a right for users to take part in or be notified of policy changes.

Supporting quotations

Creating a new policy or making a policy change requires in-depth research around trends in online behavior, developing clear external language that sets expectations around what’s allowed, and creating enforcement guidance for reviewers that can be scaled across millions of posts.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how or when users are told about a policy change.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice

Policy drafts get internal and Trust & Safety Council feedback before enforcement starts

While drafting policy language, the publisher gathers feedback from a variety of internal teams and from its Trust & Safety Council, to consider global perspectives and how rules are applied and interpreted in different cultural and social contexts. After that, it trains its global review teams, updates the X Rules, and starts enforcing the new policy. The page describes this as the sequence followed; it names no external public consultation step.

Supporting quotations

we gather feedback from a variety of internal teams as well as our Trust & Safety Council
Finally, we train our global review teams, update the

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The feedback sources named are internal teams and the Trust & Safety Council.
  • Enforcement starts after review teams are trained and the X Rules are updated.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say who sits on the Trust & Safety Council or whether users or the public are consulted.

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

X encourages open debate and promotes counterspeech

The page says the service empowers people to understand different sides of an issue and encourages dissenting opinions to be discussed openly, which it says lets many forms of speech exist and promotes counterspeech. Counterspeech is described as speech that presents facts to correct misstatements, points out hypocrisy or contradictions, warns of consequences, denounces hateful or dangerous speech, or helps change minds and disarm. This describes the publisher's approach and does not by itself say which speech is removed.

Supporting quotations

We empower people to understand different sides of an issue and encourage dissenting opinions and viewpoints to be discussed openly.
promotes counterspeech: speech that presents facts to correct misstatements or misperceptions

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice

X may weigh context factors when deciding on enforcement action

The page says context matters and that, when deciding whether to take enforcement action, X may consider a number of factors, including but not limited to five it lists: whether the behavior is directed at an individual, group or protected category; whether the report was filed by the target or a bystander; the user's history of violating policies; the severity of the violation; and whether the content may be of legitimate public interest. The list is not exhaustive and the wording is may consider, so none of these factors is stated to decide an outcome on its own.

Supporting quotations

Thus, context matters. When determining whether to take enforcement action, we may consider a number of factors, including (but not limited to) whether:
the behavior is directed at an individual, group, or protected category of people;
the report has been filed by the target of the abuse or a bystander;
the user has a history of violating our policies;
the severity of the violation;
the content may be a topic of legitimate public interest.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The factors are listed as including, but not limited to, these five.
  • Stated as what X may consider, not as a fixed test.

Not stated here

  • Other factors X may weigh are not named on this page.
  • The report form linked from the source is a separate document; its text is not supplied here, so this card cannot say what it contains.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice

X enforces against abuse aimed at a person or group when someone reports it

To balance allowing different opinions and protecting users, the page says X enforces policies when someone reports abusive behavior that targets a specific person or group of people. It says targeting can occur in several ways, such as @mentions, tagging a photo or naming the person. The wording ties enforcement here to a report and to targeting, and the examples are illustrative (and more).

Supporting quotations

we enforce policies when someone reports abusive behavior that targets a specific person or group of people
This targeting can happen in a number of ways (for example, @mentions, tagging a photo, mentioning them by name, and more).

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies to abusive behavior that targets a specific person or group.
  • Triggered by a report, as the page words it.
  • The ways of targeting listed are examples.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say whether X also acts on abuse it finds without a report.

Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception

In certain scenarios X requires a report from the target before acting

The page says some posts can look abusive alone but not in the context of a larger conversation or relationship, giving friendly banter and cultural differences as examples. To avoid removing consensual interactions, in certain scenarios X requires a report from the actual target or their authorized representative before taking any enforcement action. The page does not say which scenarios these are.

Supporting quotations

in certain scenarios we require a report from the actual target (or their authorized representative) prior to taking any enforcement action
friendly banter between friends could appear offensive to bystanders

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies only in certain scenarios, which are not specified.
  • The report must come from the target or their authorized representative, not a bystander.

Not stated here

  • Which scenarios require a target report is not stated on this page.
  • The report form linked in this passage is a separate document whose text is not supplied here, so this card cannot say what it requires.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

X first educates and corrects, then escalates enforcement for repeat violations

The page says X starts from assuming people do not intend to violate its Rules. Unless a violation is so egregious that an account must be suspended immediately, X first tries to educate people and give them a chance to correct their behavior: it shows the offending post or posts, explains the Rule broken, and requires removal before the person can post again. For repeated violations, enforcement becomes stronger, including required removal and actions such as verifying account ownership or temporarily limiting the ability to post for a set period. If someone continues beyond that point, the account may be permanently suspended.

Supporting quotations

Unless a violation is so egregious that we must immediately suspend an account, we first try to educate people about our Rules and give them a chance to correct their behavior.
require them to remove the content before they can post again
verifying account ownership and/or temporarily limiting their ability to post for a set period of time
then their account may be permanently suspended

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Egregious violations skip the educate step.
  • Stronger steps apply to repeated violations.
  • Permanent suspension is described as something that may happen after continued violations.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how many violations count as repeated or how long a temporary limit lasts (a set period).

Cross-references

  • has exception (model-proposed): Egregious violations lead to immediate and permanent suspension — The educate-first approach is stated to apply unless a violation is so egregious that the account must be suspended immediately; the severity passage names the egregious behaviors that lead to immediate permanent suspension.

Account & Service Control · Company practice

Egregious violations lead to immediate and permanent suspension

The page says certain behavior that poses serious safety and security risks or causes physical, emotional or financial hardship results in immediate and permanent account suspension, naming violent threats, non-consensual intimate media and content that sexually exploits children as examples. Other violations could lead to a range of steps, like required removal of posts or temporarily limiting the ability to post. The list of egregious examples is introduced by such as, so it is not complete.

Supporting quotations

result in the immediate and permanent suspension of an account
such as posting violent threats, non-consensual intimate media, or content that sexually exploits children
Other violations could lead to a range of different steps

Qualifications & exceptions

  • The named examples are illustrative.
  • Other violations lead to a range of steps rather than immediate permanent suspension.

Not stated here

  • The page does not list every behavior that counts as egregious.

Cross-references

Content & IP Rights · Restriction or exception

X may let rule-breaking content stay up in the rare case of legitimate public interest

The page says there may be a rare occasion when X allows controversial content or behavior that may otherwise violate its Rules to remain on the service because it believes there is legitimate public interest in its availability. Each situation is evaluated case by case and ultimately decided by a cross-functional team. The stated purpose is to help people see every side of an issue. This is a discretionary exception, not a right of any user or account.

Supporting quotations

there may be the rare occasion when we allow controversial content or behavior which may otherwise violate our Rules to remain on our service because we believe there is a legitimate public interest in its availability
Each situation is evaluated on a case by case basis and ultimately decided upon by a cross-functional team.
Exposure to different viewpoints can help people learn from one another, become more tolerant, and make decisions about the type of society we want to live in.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Described as rare.
  • Decided case by case by a cross-functional team.
  • Discretionary (may).

Not stated here

  • The page does not say who is on the cross-functional team or whether affected users are told of such a decision.

Cross-references

  • contrast (model-proposed): X says it enforces the X Rules with uniform consistency — The page says X strives to enforce the Rules with uniform consistency, and also says it may let rule-breaking content stay up on rare occasions, case by case, for legitimate public interest. The two statements sit together; the page does not explain how they are reconciled.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Content & IP Rights · Company practice

Public impact, source and coverage inform public-interest decisions; minimal impact is usually removed

The page names the impact on the public, the source of the content and the availability of alternative coverage as factors that help inform decisions. On impact, it says a topic of legitimate public interest differs from one the public is merely curious about; X considers what the impact on citizens would be if they did not know, and may let content stay if it could affect large numbers of people, the running of a country, or an important societal issue. If public impact is minimal, X will most likely remove violating content. On source, some people, groups and organizations may be of public interest by being in the public consciousness, but that does not mean their posts will always remain; X considers whether a particular post's availability is of legitimate public interest. The factor of alternative coverage is only named here.

Supporting quotations

the impact it may have on the public, the source of the content, and the availability of alternative coverage of an event
A topic of legitimate public interest is different from a topic in which the public may be curious.
if the impact on the public is minimal we will most likely remove content in violation of our policies
This does not mean that their posts will always remain on the service.

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Factors are those that help inform the decision, not a complete or fixed test.
  • Being a public figure or organization does not guarantee posts remain.
  • Outcomes are phrased as may allow and most likely remove.

Not stated here

  • How the factors are weighed against each other is not stated.
Also annotated in the same passage (1)

Content & IP Rights · Company commitment

X says it will weigh a post's role in the larger story and whether it is available elsewhere before acting

The page says that, because people provide firsthand accounts, counterpoints to establishment views and sometimes expose abuse of power, removing access to information as a situation unfolds could hide context or stop people seeing every side. It therefore says that before actioning a potentially violating post, X will take into account the role the post plays in showing the larger story and whether the content can be found elsewhere. This is one of the public-interest factors; it states a consideration, not that such posts will stay up. Elsewhere on the page, public-interest decisions are made case by case by a cross-functional team, and X considers whether there is legitimate public interest for a particular post to remain up.

Supporting quotations

Thus, before actioning a potentially violating post, we will take into account the role it plays in showing the larger story and whether that content can be found elsewhere.
removing access to certain information could inadvertently hide context and/or prevent people from seeing every side of the issue
Each situation is evaluated on a case by case basis and ultimately decided upon by a cross-functional team.
we will consider if there is a legitimate public interest for a particular post to remain up so it can be openly discussed

Qualifications & exceptions

  • Applies before actioning a potentially violating post.
  • It is a consideration X says it will take into account, not a promise about the outcome.

Not stated here

  • The page does not say how much weight this consideration carries against the Rules.
Also annotated in the same passage (2)