X handles copyright complaints under the DMCA and similar notice-and-takedown laws
X says it responds to copyright complaints submitted under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) or other applicable copyright notice-and-takedown laws. The policy points to Section 512 of the DMCA as setting the statutory requirements for formally reporting infringement and for an affected party to appeal a removal with a compliant counter-notice, and says similar requirements exist under various other notice-and-takedown laws. The policy names no other law and does not list those other laws.
Supporting quotations
responds to copyright complaints under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the procedures for reporting infringement and submitting counter-notices.
Section 512 of the DMCA outlines the statutory requirements necessary for formally reporting copyright infringement
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to complaints submitted under the DMCA or other applicable notice-and-takedown laws.
Not stated here
Which other notice-and-takedown laws X applies is not stated.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Context
X does not give legal advice about who holds copyright
X says it cannot provide legal advice and suggests that a person unsure whether they hold rights to a work, or whether they are infringing someone else's work, consult an attorney or another adviser. It lists outside resources for learning about copyright law. It also states that in general the photographer, not the subject of a photograph, is the rights holder of the resulting photograph.
Supporting quotations
please consult an attorney or another adviser as
cannot provide legal advice.
In general, the photographer and NOT the subject of a photograph is the actual rights holder of the resulting photograph.
Qualifications & exceptions
The photographer statement is introduced with "In general", so it is a general statement, not a rule without exceptions.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
Before filing, X asks reporters to consider fair use and to contact the user
Before submitting a complaint, X asks the reporter to consider whether the use could be fair use. If the reporter still wishes to continue, X says they may want to contact the user first, by replying to the post or sending a Direct Message, to ask for removal without contacting X. These are suggestions ("please consider", "you may want to"), not conditions of filing stated in this document.
Supporting quotations
Before submitting a copyright complaint to us, please consider whether or not the use could be considered
you may want to first reach out to the user in question to see if you can resolve the matter directly with the user.
Qualifications & exceptions
Phrased as a request and a suggestion, not as a mandatory step.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception
Knowingly misrepresenting infringement can make a reporter liable for damages
X warns that under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) or other applicable laws, a person who knowingly materially misrepresents that material or activity is infringing may be liable for damages, including costs and attorneys' fees incurred by X or its users. X suggests contacting an attorney if unsure whether the material is infringing. The policy cites the statute but does not describe its text beyond this warning, and the warning says "may be liable", not that liability always follows.
Supporting quotations
under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) or other applicable laws, you may be liable for any damages, including costs and attorneys’ fees incurred by us or our users, if you knowingly materially misrepresent that material or activity is infringing.
Qualifications & exceptions
Applies to a reporter who knowingly materially misrepresents that material or activity is infringing.
Liability is stated as "may".
Not stated here
The statute itself is not supplied; its terms beyond the policy's description are unknown.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
A copyright notice must contain six listed items
To submit a notice of claimed copyright infringement, the reporter must provide: a physical or electronic signature (typing a full name suffices) of the copyright owner or an authorized person; identification of the copyrighted work; identification of the infringing material with information reasonably sufficient for X to locate it; the reporter's contact information including address, telephone number and email address; a statement of good faith belief that the use is not authorized by the owner, its agent or the law; and a statement that the information is accurate and, under penalty of perjury, that the reporter is authorized to act for the owner. For a post, X asks for a direct link to the post or a statement that the alleged infringement is in the header, avatar or similar, and says a link to a profile page is insufficient to identify infringing material.
Supporting quotations
To submit a notice of claimed copyright infringement, you will need to provide us with the following information:
A physical or electronic signature (typing your full name will suffice)
Identification of the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed
Identification of the infringing material and information reasonably sufficient to permit
Your contact information, including your address, telephone number, and an email address;
A statement that you have a good faith belief that the use of the material in the manner asserted is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law; and
A statement that the information in the complaint is accurate, and, under penalty of perjury, that you are authorized to act on behalf of the copyright owner.
A LINK TO A PROFILE PAGE IS INSUFFICIENT FOR
Qualifications & exceptions
For a post, a direct link to the post is requested, or the report must specify where in the header or avatar the alleged infringement is.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
Complaints are filed through the X Help Center form
X says alleged copyright infringement is reported by visiting its Help Center and filing a copyright complaint through a form. A person logged in to x.com can reach the Help Center from the Help link in the sidebar of their account.
Supporting quotations
You can report alleged copyright infringement by visiting
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
Complaints are usually processed in order and duplicates cause delay
X says it typically processes copyright complaints in the order received. After a ticket is submitted, X emails a ticket confirmation. A reporter who receives no confirmation is told that X did not receive the complaint and should resubmit it. Submitting duplicate complaints will delay processing.
Supporting quotations
We typically process copyright complaints in the order in which they are received.
If you do not receive a ticket confirmation that means we did not receive your complaint and you should re-submit your complaint.
submitting duplicate copyright complaints will result in a delay in processing.
Qualifications & exceptions
"Typically": the order is not guaranteed.
Not stated here
No processing time frame is stated.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice
Reporters can use an agent so their own contact details are not shown
X says a reporter uncomfortable sharing contact information with the reported user or users may appoint an agent to submit the notice on their behalf. The agent must submit the notice with valid contact information and identify the reporter as the content owner being represented.
Supporting quotations
you may wish to consider appointing an agent to submit your copyright notice on your behalf.
Your agent will be required to submit the copyright notice with valid contact information, and identify you as the content owner that they are representing.
you may wish to use an agent to report for you.
Qualifications & exceptions
The agent must supply valid contact information and name the owner, so the agent's details are what the reported user sees.
Not stated here
The policy does not say whether the agent's contact details are forwarded to the reported user, only that the agent must supply them.
A user who has not received the complaint copy should reply to the support ticket
X tells a user whose content was removed and who has not yet received a copy of the complaint to respond to the support ticket X sent.
Supporting quotations
please respond to the support ticket we sent you.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
Deleting the reported material does not resolve a complaint; a retraction can
X says removing the reported material does not resolve the complaint, and that deleting the remaining part of a partly withheld post does not resolve the violation. X says the fastest way to resolve an unresolved DMCA complaint is to ask the reporter, whose contact information is in the complaint, to retract it, using X's retraction form or by emailing a retraction notice to copyright@x.com that identifies the disabled material and says the reporter wants to retract. A retraction is at the sole discretion of the original reporter, and only that reporter can issue one.
Supporting quotations
Removing the material reported in a copyright complaint will not resolve that complaint
This is the fastest and most efficient means of resolving an unresolved copyright complaint.
A retraction is at the sole discretion of the original reporter, and only that reporter can issue a retraction.
If a portion of your post has been withheld, the violation will not be resolved just by deleting the remaining portion.
Qualifications & exceptions
Only the original reporter can retract, and doing so is at that reporter's sole discretion.
Not stated here
The policy does not say how the complaint is resolved if the reporter refuses to retract other than through a counter-notice.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · User right or choice
A user who thinks content was misidentified or removed in error can appeal and file a counter-notice
A user who believes the reported material was misidentified or removed in error may send an appeal and counter-notification through the Help Center. X describes a counter-notice as a request for X to reinstate the removed material and says it has legal consequences. A user may alternatively seek a retraction of the complaint from the reporter.
Supporting quotations
you may send us an
A counter-notice is a request for
it has legal consequences. Alternatively, you may be able to seek a retraction of the copyright complaint from the reporter.
Qualifications & exceptions
Available to a user who believes the reported materials were misidentified or removed in error.
Not stated here
The policy does not say whether an appeal is decided separately from the counter-notice.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception
A counter-notice starts a legal process, with court consent and contact details shared with the reporter
X says a counter-notice is a request to reinstate removed material and is the start of a legal process with legal consequences. As an example, submitting one indicates consent to the jurisdiction of a U.S. Federal court and consent to the disclosure of the user's personal information to the reporter. On receiving a valid counter-notice, X says it will promptly forward a copy to the original reporter, so the contact information submitted in it is shared with the reporter.
Supporting quotations
is the start of a legal process that has legal consequences.
submitting a counter notice indicates that you consent to the jurisdiction of a U.S. Federal court and that you consent to the disclosure of your personal information to the reporter.
Upon receipt of a valid counter-notice, we will promptly forward a copy to the person who filed the original notice.
This means that the contact information that is submitted in your counter-notice will be shared to the person who filed the original notice.
Qualifications & exceptions
Sharing applies to a valid counter-notice.
The consent to U.S. Federal court jurisdiction is introduced with "For example", so the legal consequences are not limited to it.
Not stated here
Consequences beyond the example are not described.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
A counter-notice must include five items, and a web form is used to submit it
A counter-notice must contain: a physical or electronic signature (typing a full name suffices); the user's full name, address including country, telephone number and, for verification, their X username and associated email; identification of the removed or disabled material and where it appeared before (the description from the copyright notice suffices); a statement under penalty of perjury of good faith belief that the material was removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification; and one of two jurisdictional consent statements. All of it must be provided using X's web form.
Supporting quotations
To submit a counter-notice, you will need to provide us with the following information:
A physical or electronic signature (typing your full name will suffice);
Your full name, address (including country), telephone number, and for verification purposes, your
Identification of the material that has been removed or to which access has been disabled
A statement under penalty of perjury that you have a good faith belief that the material was removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification
One of the following jurisdictional consent statements:
please provide all of the above information using our web form
Not stated here
The linked counter-notice web form is not supplied in this source, so its fields and any further requirements are unknown.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Procedure
The counter-notice jurisdiction statement depends on whether your address is in the United States
A counter-notice must include one of two statements. A user whose address is in the United States consents to the jurisdiction of the Federal District Court for the judicial district where the address is located and accepts service of process from the person who gave notice under 17 U.S.C. 512(c)(1)(C) or that person's agent. A user whose address is outside the United States consents to any judicial district in which X may be found and accepts service of process from that person or agent. The statute is named in the statements; its text is not supplied.
Supporting quotations
(If your address is in the United States)
I consent to the jurisdiction of the Federal District Court for the judicial district in which my address is located
(If your address is outside of the United States)
I consent to any judicial district in which
Qualifications & exceptions
Which statement applies depends on where the user's address is.
Not stated here
The text of 17 U.S.C. 512(c)(1)(C) is not supplied, so what service of process it covers is not explained here.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Company practice
Without notice of a court action within 10 business days, X may restore the material
X says that if the copyright owner disagrees that content was removed in error or through misidentification, the owner may pursue legal action against the user. If X does not receive notice within 10 business days that the original reporter is seeking a court order to prevent further infringement, X may replace or cease disabling access to the removed material. The wording is "may", so restoration is not promised.
Supporting quotations
they may pursue legal action against you.
If we do not receive notice within 10 business days that the original reporter is seeking a court order to prevent further infringement of the material at issue, we may replace or cease disabling access to the material that was removed.
Qualifications & exceptions
Restoration is permissive ("may"), and depends on not receiving notice of a court action within 10 business days.
Not stated here
The policy does not say when the 10 business days begin or how X is notified.
Legal Rights & Agreement Rules · Restriction or exception
Re-posting removed material or filing a bad-faith claim can have serious consequences
X warns that re-posting material removed in response to a copyright complaint may result in permanent account suspension, and asks a user who thinks the content was removed in error to file a counter-notice instead. X also warns that there are legal and financial consequences for fraudulent or bad faith claims or counter-notices, asks people to be sure they are the rights holder or have a good faith belief of error, and says it cannot offer legal advice.
Supporting quotations
Re-posting material removed in response to a copyright complaint may result in permanent account suspension.
please file a counter-notice rather than re-posting the material.
We cannot offer any legal advice.
There are legal and financial consequences for fraudulent and/or bad faith submissions.
Qualifications & exceptions
Suspension for re-posting is stated as "may".
Not stated here
The policy does not describe what the legal and financial consequences are.