Spam, mass messages and collecting replies to bulk messages are prohibited
The Policy prohibits transmitting unsolicited bulk or commercial messages (“spam”), sending very large numbers of the same or substantially similar messages, empty messages or messages with no substantive content, and sending very large messages or files that disrupt a server, account, blog, newsgroup, chat or similar service. It also prohibits collecting responses from unsolicited bulk messages.
Supporting quotations
transmit unsolicited bulk or commercial messages commonly known as “spam;”
send very large numbers of copies of the same or substantially similar messages, empty messages, or messages which contain no substantive content, or send very large messages or files that disrupts a server, account, blog, newsgroup, chat, or similar service;
collect responses from unsolicited bulk messages;
Qualifications & exceptions
“Very large” is not defined by a number in this text.
Not stated here
The policy gives no numeric threshold for “very large numbers” of messages or “very large” messages or files.
Use & Processing · Restriction or exception
Dedicated stand-alone servers that serve anyone outside your Premises LAN are prohibited
You may not use or run dedicated, stand-alone equipment or servers from the Premises that provide network content or any other services to anyone outside your Premises local area network. Comcast calls these public services or servers and gives email, web hosting, file sharing and proxy services and servers as examples. This item states no personal-use exception on its face.
Supporting quotations
use or run dedicated, stand-alone equipment or servers from the Premises that provide network content or any other services to anyone outside of your Premises local area network (“Premises LAN”), also commonly referred to as public services or servers.
Examples of prohibited equipment and servers include, but are not limited to, email, web hosting, file sharing, and proxy services and servers;
Qualifications & exceptions
Covers dedicated, stand-alone equipment or servers that provide services outside the Premises LAN; the examples are not exhaustive.
Not stated here
“Premises” is not defined in this text.
The next item allows non-dedicated programs, devices or equipment for personal and non-commercial residential use; the text does not say whether that exception also reaches dedicated equipment.
Programs and devices serving people outside your Premises LAN are barred, except for personal residential use
You may not use or run programs, devices or equipment from the Premises that provide network content or other services to anyone outside your Premises LAN, except for your personal and non-commercial residential use. Unlike the dedicated-server item, this one carries an express exception for personal, non-commercial residential use.
Supporting quotations
use or run programs, devices, or equipment from the Premises that provide network content or any other services to anyone outside of your Premises LAN, except for your personal and non-commercial residential use;
Qualifications & exceptions
Exception limited to personal and non-commercial residential use.
Not stated here
The text does not say how this item’s exception relates to the dedicated, stand-alone equipment item just before it.
Cross-references
contrast (model-proposed): Dedicated stand-alone servers that serve anyone outside your Premises LAN are prohibited — Two adjacent items address serving people outside the Premises LAN. The dedicated, stand-alone equipment item states no personal-use exception, while the programs, devices or equipment item excepts personal and non-commercial residential use. The text does not say how the two fit together.
Use & Processing · Permission or license
Comcast has no duty to monitor transmissions but may monitor them and disclose, block or remove violations
Neither Comcast nor its affiliates, suppliers or agents have any obligation to monitor transmissions or postings made on the Service, such as email, file transfer, blog, newsgroup and instant message transmissions. Comcast and its affiliates, suppliers and agents nonetheless have the right to monitor those transmissions and postings from time to time for violations of the Policy, and to disclose, block or remove them in accordance with the Policy, the Subscriber Agreement and applicable law.
Supporting quotations
Neither Comcast nor any of its affiliates, suppliers, or agents have any obligation to monitor transmissions or postings (including, but not limited to, email, file transfer, blog, newsgroup, and instant message transmissions) made on the Service.
However, Comcast and its affiliates, suppliers, and agents have the right to monitor these transmissions and postings from time to time for violations of this Policy and to disclose, block, or remove them in accordance with this Policy, the Subscriber Agreement, and applicable law.
Qualifications & exceptions
Monitoring is “from time to time” for violations of the Policy; disclosure, blocking or removal is “in accordance with” the Policy, the Subscriber Agreement and applicable law.
Not stated here
The text does not say to whom Comcast may disclose monitored content outside the Policy’s later cooperation provision, or what limits the Subscriber Agreement places on it.
Email may not be used in violation of the prohibited-uses section; Comcast applies anti-spam network management
The Service may not be used to communicate or distribute email or other communications in violation of Section I of the Policy. Comcast says it uses reasonable network management tools and techniques, which it says are described “below in Section III,” to protect customers from receiving spam and from sending spam, often without their knowledge from an infected computer. Its anti-spam approach is explained in separate FAQs that are not supplied. The Policy cites Roman-numeral sections while its headings use Arabic numerals; the text does not state the correspondence.
Supporting quotations
The Service may not be used to communicate or distribute email or other forms of communications in violation of Section I of this Policy.
Comcast uses reasonable network management tools and techniques to protect customers from receiving spam and from sending spam (often without their knowledge over an infected computer).
Not stated here
The cited “Section I” and “Section III” are Roman-numeral references and the document does not state which headings they mean.
The anti-spam FAQ it links is not supplied.
Use & Processing · Company practice
Comcast manages its network with reasonable, evolving practices, including enforcing the Policy
Comcast says it manages its network to deliver the best possible broadband Internet experience to all customers, that bandwidth and network resources are not unlimited, and that it uses reasonable network management practices consistent with industry standards. It describes its tools as minimally intrusive and among the best in class in its own independent judgment, and says its practices will change and evolve with how the Internet is used. It also says that enforcing the Policy is part of that management. A link to a separate Network Management page is given for more information.
Supporting quotations
The company uses reasonable network management practices that are consistent with industry standards.
Comcast tries to use tools and technologies that are minimally intrusive and, in its independent judgment guided by industry experience, among the best in class.
the company’s network management practices will change and evolve along with the uses of the Internet and the challenges and threats on the Internet.
By engaging in responsible network management including enforcement of this Policy, Comcast can deliver the best possible broadband Internet experience to all of its customers.
Qualifications & exceptions
“Minimally intrusive” and “best in class” are Comcast’s own independent judgment.
Practices are stated to change over time.
Not stated here
The separate Network Management page is linked but not supplied, so its specific practices are not analyzed.
Use & Processing · Company practice
Network management may include spam filtering, malware detection and lowering priority for top congestion users
Comcast uses tools and techniques to manage its network, deliver the Service, and ensure compliance with the Policy and the Subscriber Agreement; it says they are dynamic and change frequently. Its examples of these activities are identifying spam and preventing its delivery to customer email accounts, detecting malicious Internet traffic and preventing distribution of viruses or other harmful code, and temporarily lowering the priority of traffic for users who are the top contributors to current network congestion. It adds other tools and techniques it may be required to implement, so the list is not exhaustive.
Supporting quotations
these network management activities may include (i) identifying spam and preventing its delivery to customer email accounts, (ii) detecting malicious Internet traffic and preventing the distribution of viruses or other harmful code or content, (iii) temporarily lowering the priority of traffic for users who are the top contributors to current network congestion, and (iv) using other tools and techniques that Comcast may be required to implement
These tools and techniques are dynamic, like the network and its usage, and can and do change frequently.
Qualifications & exceptions
The examples are introduced by “may include” and end with a catch-all item.
Lowering priority is described as temporary and aimed at users who are the top contributors to current network congestion.
Not stated here
The text does not say how “top contributors” are identified, what threshold applies, or how long lowered priority lasts.
Use & Processing · Company practice
Comcast does not routinely monitor individual accounts, except aggregate data consumption, but may monitor at any time
Comcast says it does not routinely monitor the activity of individual Service accounts for violations of the Policy, except for determining aggregate data consumption in connection with “Section IV” of the Policy. It says it will respond appropriately if it becomes aware of inappropriate use, and that it has no obligation to monitor the Service or the network. Comcast and its suppliers nonetheless reserve the right at any time to monitor bandwidth, usage, transmissions and content to operate the Service, identify violations of the Policy, and protect the network, the Service and Comcast users.
Supporting quotations
Comcast does not routinely monitor the activity of individual Service accounts for violations of this Policy, except for determining aggregate data consumption in connection with Section IV of this Policy.
Comcast has no obligation to monitor the Service and/or the network.
Comcast and its suppliers reserve the right at any time to monitor bandwidth, usage, transmissions, and content in order to, among other things, operate the Service; identify violations of this Policy; and/or protect the network, the Service and Comcast users.
Qualifications & exceptions
“Routinely” is limited to individual-account monitoring for violations; aggregate data consumption is the stated exception.
The reserved right to monitor is stated “at any time” and “among other things.”
Not stated here
The text cites “Section IV” in Roman numerals while its headings are numbered with Arabic numerals (“4. Data Consumption”); it does not state the correspondence.
“Among other things” leaves open other purposes for monitoring that are not listed.
Use & Processing · Permission or license
Comcast may investigate suspected violations, examine data on its servers and network, and suspend or block meanwhile
Comcast reserves the right to investigate suspected violations of the Policy. That includes gathering information from the user or users involved and the complaining party, if any, and examining material and data on Comcast’s servers and network. During an investigation, Comcast may suspend the account or accounts involved and may remove or block material that potentially violates the Policy.
Supporting quotations
Comcast reserves the right to investigate suspected violations of this Policy, including the gathering of information from the user or users involved and the complaining party, if any, and examination of material and data on Comcast’s servers and network.
During an investigation, Comcast may suspend the account or accounts involved and/or remove or block material that potentially violates this Policy.
Qualifications & exceptions
Suspension or blocking during an investigation reaches material that “potentially” violates the Policy, not only confirmed violations.
Not stated here
The text does not describe what information is gathered beyond “material and data on Comcast’s servers and network,” or how long an investigation may last.