On November 9, Judge Edward J. Davila of the Northern District of California granted arbitration in Pflaumer v. Ace Hardware Corporation and paused the lawsuit pending arbitration.
The plaintiffs allege that Ace continued tracking and sharing their data after they selected necessary cookies only. The banner also stated that selecting any option meant accepting its linked terms of use, which included arbitration.
Applying California contract law, Davila held that the banner clearly connected the selection to acceptance. He emphasized the prominent blue, bold, underlined terms link directly above the buttons and the contrasting white banner.
The judge nevertheless rejected a provision barring relief benefiting the public, removing that restriction while enforcing arbitration. The decision concerns this banner and these plaintiffs; it does not make every cookie selection contractual consent or decide whether Ace violated privacy law. Read the November 9 court order, reproduced by Justia.