Karl Kahn and Solomon Smith allege that they bought Max subscriptions expecting five or twenty times as much Claude usage as Pro subscribers over each paid month. They say the advertised multipliers applied only within individual five-hour sessions, while a separate weekly cap limited how much they could use across those sessions.
According to their calculations for the Sonnet 4 model, the weekly allowances amounted to approximately 3.5 times Pro’s usage for Max 5x and six times Pro’s usage for Max 20x. They allege that the larger session allowances did not deliver the corresponding increase over a full subscription month because the weekly cap intervened. Those figures describe the allegations before the court, not independently verified current plan limits.
In a November 6, 2026 order in Kahn v. Anthropic PBC, U.S. Magistrate Judge Alex G. Tse of the Northern District of California held that the subscribers had adequately pleaded a breach of contract. The terms directed customers to the ordering process for subscription details, supporting their argument that the advertised usage multipliers formed part of their contracts. The explanation limiting those multipliers to individual sessions appeared two links away, outside the required signup process. Anthropic’s authority to change capacity limits did not defeat the claim, which concerned usage relative to Pro rather than a fixed allowance.
The court dismissed a separate claim that Anthropic violated its duty of good faith by changing subscriptions during billing periods customers had already paid for. The subscribers alleged that changes reduced available usage, caused allowances to run out faster, and extended premium features to cheaper or free plans. The court held that the terms expressly permitted changes to features and capacity limits, and that the complaint did not adequately allege an abuse of that discretion. In particular, the alleged effort to manage demand exceeding available capacity did not establish bad faith.
The subscribers may amend the dismissed claims by December 2. The order did not certify a class.