Skip to reports
thicPRINT

Supreme Court to hear Apple Card dispute over arbitration in bankruptcy

Published

TL;DR: The U.S. Supreme Court will consider whether Apple Card customers must arbitrate claims that Goldman Sachs continued collecting debts after bankruptcy filings required collection to stop. Lower courts allowed the customers to pursue those claims in bankruptcy court despite their arbitration agreements. The Supreme Court has agreed to review that decision; it has not decided which forum must hear the claims.

The justices accepted Goldman Sachs Bank USA v. Brown, No. 25-1408, on November 6. The appeal concerns the reach of arbitration clauses when customers seek damages for violations of bankruptcy’s automatic stay—the protection that generally halts collection of debts owed before a bankruptcy filing. Supreme Court order granting review.

Apple Card customers Rhea Ann Brown and Gregory Kevin Maze sued the card’s issuer, Goldman Sachs, in federal bankruptcy court in Virginia. They allege the bank continued contacting them about unpaid balances after receiving notice of their bankruptcy filings. Their proposed class action seeks damages and an order stopping the challenged collection practices.

Goldman Sachs asked to move the claims into individual arbitration, relying on the customers’ Apple Card agreements. Brown and Maze did not dispute that they had accepted valid arbitration provisions covering their claims. The disagreement concerns whether bankruptcy law nevertheless permits a judge to keep the claims in court.

On March 18, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the refusal to compel arbitration. The majority concluded that arbitration would interfere with the Bankruptcy Code’s purposes in this case, including the bankruptcy court’s enforcement of the automatic stay. Fourth Circuit opinion.

The Supreme Court’s review will address when a bankruptcy court may refuse to enforce an otherwise valid arbitration agreement for these claims. The eventual ruling could determine where consumers can seek compensation for unlawful collection during bankruptcy. Accepting the appeal does not establish that Goldman Sachs violated the stay or entitle either customer to compensation. Petition and appended lower-court decisions; official Supreme Court docket.

← Back to The Terms Report