The Wolcott Family Living Trust, Tyche Investment Fund, Noelle Wolcott and Ryan Weber sued the investment firm CASL, LLC and Christopher Arends. The complaint alleges that Arends persuaded the plaintiffs to invest in the cryptocurrency hedge fund promoted by CASL through oral promises about how their money would be invested and when it could be withdrawn. The plaintiffs say the money was not invested as promised and was not returned when requested.
Arends asked the Multnomah County Circuit Court to send the fraud claims against him to private arbitration, citing CASL’s Note Purchase Agreement. The trial court refused, and Arends appealed.
The arbitration argument depended on CASL’s online signup process. A link to the investment contract appeared beside a checkbox with this instruction: “By checking this box you certify that the information you entered is correct.” After the box was checked, the website automatically added the user’s typed name and the date to the contract.
Arends argued that completing this process meant accepting the contract, including its arbitration clause. Arends also pointed to a warning displayed when someone tried to continue without checking the box: “You must agree to the terms to proceed.”
The plaintiffs told the trial court that Arends had never mentioned arbitration when explaining the investment orally. In written declarations submitted to the court, the plaintiffs said they had not noticed the link or read the contract before the lawsuit.
The Oregon Court of Appeals concluded that the plaintiffs could reasonably have understood the checkbox as confirming their information alone. Providing a link to the contract did not, by itself, establish acceptance of its terms.
The November 4, 2026 decision in Wolcott Family Living Trust v. CASL, LLC, No. A183856, upheld the trial court’s finding that the plaintiffs had not agreed to arbitration. The court did not decide whether Arends committed fraud.