The November 4, 2026 decision in Nader v. LendingTree, No. 25-7045, upheld a Montana federal court’s refusal to compel arbitration in the Snowflake data-breach litigation.
The four plaintiffs had supplied personal information while seeking loan or insurance quotes. They allege that attackers stole that information from Snowflake’s cloud, where LendingTree had stored it. LendingTree and QuoteWizard sought to enforce website terms requiring individual arbitration and waiving class actions. Trial court’s October 30, 2025 order.
The appeals court found that both websites drew attention away from the contract notices. The notices used much smaller type than surrounding content. QuoteWizard’s form required scrolling past prominent text and a green “Get My Quotes” button. LendingTree placed its terms link well below “View Your Rates,” among other links.
Because the pages did not give reasonably conspicuous notice, the court concluded that the consumers had not agreed to the terms. Their claims therefore remain outside arbitration under this ruling.
The decision applies existing contract principles to the pages presented in this case. It is not binding precedent, except in the limited circumstances allowed by Ninth Circuit rules. November 4 appellate decision, reproduced by Justia.