In an October 26, 2026 ruling, the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon allowed a patient privacy lawsuit against Providence Health & Services to proceed. The patients allege that the healthcare provider collected sensitive health information through tracking tools on its website and patient portal and shared it with outside companies for marketing without their permission.
Providence argued that patients had accepted these practices when creating their accounts. The company submitted its Terms of Use & Privacy Policy and a screenshot showing a checkbox that users had to select before accessing the portal.
The company had not shown that the policy and signup page were the versions in place when the alleged tracking occurred. The patients also disputed that they had consented. Judge Mustafa T. Kasubhai declined to treat their use of the portal as proof that they had accepted those data practices.
The ruling in McClellan v. Providence Health & Services allows the patients to pursue their claims. Whether they consented to the tracking and whether Providence violated the law remain unresolved.