Skip to reports
thicPRINT

Court rejects Sony’s arbitration bid in smart-TV privacy lawsuit

Published

TL;DR: A California federal judge rejected Sony’s attempt to send customers’ smart-TV privacy claims to arbitration. The warranty paperwork did not adequately alert them to that obligation. The ruling does not establish that Sony violated privacy laws.

Judge Marilyn L. Huff issued the November 2, 2026, order in In re Sony Electronics Privacy Litigation, No. 26-cv-00297, in the Southern District of California. Buyers allege Sony collected and sold viewing data without consent.

Sony argued customers accepted arbitration by using their TVs and failing to opt out. Applying California law, the court found inadequate notice that a document labeled “Limited Warranty” imposed obligations beyond warranty coverage. Nothing on the packaging alerted buyers to additional terms.

Sony also failed to explain sufficiently how its separate onscreen license agreement was presented to these customers.

Claims for public disclosure of private facts and California constitutional privacy survived. Numerous others were dismissed with 30 days to amend. The arbitration ruling turns on the notice provided to these buyers; it does not invalidate Sony’s arbitration clauses generally.

← Back to The Terms Report