Skip to reports
thicPRINT

Uber loses arbitration appeal in California fare lawsuit

Published

TL;DR: A California appeals court rejected Uber’s attempt to require arbitration in a lawsuit over allegedly misleading fares. The riders can pursue repayment and an order stopping the challenged advertising together in court. The ruling does not decide whether Uber misled customers, and trial proceedings remain paused.

The November 4, 2026 decision in Bogguess v. Uber Technologies, No. A174376, came from California’s First District Court of Appeal. Two riders allege that Uber presents the price displayed before a ride as the final fare but frequently charges more. Their proposed class action seeks repayment of the alleged overcharges and an order stopping Uber from advertising prices below what customers ultimately pay.

Uber’s January 2023 terms required individual arbitration. The terms also barred riders from asking a court or arbitrator to order changes protecting other customers, such as stopping the allegedly misleading fare advertising.

The appeals court held that stopping that advertising would protect potential Uber customers. The riders were therefore seeking a public injunction—an order intended to prevent harm to the public. California law prohibits an agreement from eliminating the right to seek a public injunction in both court and arbitration.

Uber argued that the riders should still have to seek repayment in arbitration, leaving only the request to stop the advertising in court. Uber’s terms also explained what would happen if a court refused to enforce the ban on public injunctions: the claims covered by the ban would be heard in court. The wording did not clearly distinguish between the riders’ entire legal claims, including repayment, and their request for a public injunction alone.

The appeals court resolved that ambiguity against Uber and upheld the trial court’s refusal to compel arbitration, allowing the riders to pursue both requests together in court. The decision does not award repayment or require Uber to change its advertising.

The lawsuit remains paused pending the formal return of the case from the appeals court to the San Francisco trial court.

← Back to The Terms Report