Skip to reports
thicPRINT

Ninth Circuit rejects Yippee bid to send subscriber dispute to arbitration

Published

TL;DR: A federal appeals court ruled that Yippee, a Christian streaming service for children, failed to establish that a subscriber accepted arbitration through its signup page. The November 5 decision leaves the dispute in court because the page did not clearly identify which click would constitute agreement.

In Morrison v. Yippee Entertainment, the Ninth Circuit affirmed a Southern District of California order denying Yippee’s motion to compel Brittany Morrison to arbitrate.

The signup notice said users agreed to terms by “clicking below.” Six clickable items appeared beneath it: links to Yippee’s terms, cookie policy and privacy policy; the “Start Subscription” button; and links to Google’s terms and privacy policy.

Applying California law, the appeals court held that the notice did not clearly connect acceptance of the terms to clicking “Start Subscription.”

That defect was enough to uphold the lower court’s refusal to order arbitration, so the appeals court did not evaluate the lower court’s other reasons. The decision does not resolve Morrison’s underlying claims.

The appeals court designated its decision as unpublished, meaning it generally cannot serve as binding precedent in other cases.

← Back to The Terms Report